Skip to main content
. 2015 Jan 28;2015(1):CD001957. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001957.pub6
Date Event Description
5 September 2014 New search has been performed Searches conducted. We identified no new trials for inclusion.
5 September 2014 New citation required but conclusions have not changed Our conclusions remain unchanged.
16 April 2013 Feedback has been incorporated Feedback comment and reply added to the review.
20 November 2012 Amended Headings for Figures have been correctly labelled.
7 August 2012 New citation required but conclusions have not changed A new team of authors has taken over this previously withdrawn review.
7 August 2012 New search has been performed Due to this review update's focus on registered trademark Oscillococcinum®, the conclusions on prevention are based on different studies from those in previous versions of this review (i.e. Selkova 2005a and Selkova 2005b instead of Attena 1995 and Nollevaux 1990). Nevertheless, the results of our meta‐analyses are similar to the previous publication of this review, Vickers 2006, and the fundamental conclusion is unchanged: current evidence does not support a preventive effect of Oscillococcinum® in influenza and influenza‐like illness.
Our focus solely on reported trial data, without reference to data or other information that was missing from the original trial reports, has had an impact on our reporting of the main outcome measure for the treatment studies. Mean duration of influenza illness cannot be extracted from the two relevant papers, Ferley 1989 and Papp 1998, so patient‐reported symptom relief at 48 hours is the most closely comparable primary outcome measure we can report. Again, the adjusted focus does not alter the fundamental conclusion: Oscillococcinum® may have a beneficial treatment effect above that of placebo but the clinical importance of any such effect is unclear. Rigorous assessment of the eligible studies has designated the evidence overall as 'low quality'.
19 April 2008 Amended Converted to new review format.
27 February 2006 New search has been performed Searches conducted. Electronic literature searches were repeated in February 2006; one additional trial was found and excluded.
24 June 2003 New search has been performed Searches conducted.
10 March 2003 Feedback has been incorporated Response to feedback added to review.
4 March 2003 Feedback has been incorporated Feedback added to review.
27 February 2001 New search has been performed Searches conducted.
20 February 1999 New search has been performed Searches conducted.