Steady-state diversity is governed by a simple condition: Diversity crashes if there is an “oligotroph” whose strategy satisfies . (A) Probability of effective number of species at steady state. For each nutrient supply, we simulated 2,000 sets of 20 strategies. Strategies were chosen uniformly at random, except the case shown in red (), where oligotrophs were excluded. here and below. (B) For (orange in A), we plot all strategies that appear in the most diverse 10% of simulations (90th percentile and above of ). No strategies appear in the oligotroph region, demarcated by the blue dashed lines. (C) Same as A but for 3 nutrients. (D) Strategies that appear in the most diverse 10% of simulations for (teal in C). The oligotroph region is nearly empty.