Table 2.
Clinical trials and studies on eculizumab
Study | Number of patients | Inclusion criteria (IC) and primary end-points for patients (EP) | Number of patients with genetic mutations | Patients who received dialysis before eculizumab initiation | Patients who received PE/PI before Eculizumab initiation | Patients with history of renal transplant | Duration of study | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Legendre et al (2013) Prospective study23 |
37 17 in trial 1 20 in trial 2 ≥12 years old |
IC – trial 1: low platelet counts and renal damage Trial 2: renal damage, but no decrease in platelet count of more than 25% for at least 8 weeks during PE/PI EP – trial 1: change in platelet count Trial 2: TMA event-free status (no decrease in platelet count of >25%, no PE/PI, and no dialysis) |
13 in trial 1 and 14 in trial 2 | 5 in trial 1 and 2 in trial 2 | 16 in trial 1 and 20 in trial 2 | 7 in trial 1 and 8 in trial 2 | 26 weeks Optional extension phase: 1 year |
-Trial 1: 50% of patients had a normal platelet count after 1 week and by the end of the study, platelets and LDH levels were normal in 90% of patients. -80% were able to discontinue dialysis throughout the 26 weeks -Trial 2: 80% of the patients had TMA event-free status. -Patients discontinued PE/PI and dialysis, and had improved kidney function -Patients in both trials where eculizumab was started earlier had better improvement in renal function (P=0.007 in trial 1 and P<0.001 in trial 2) |
Licht et al (2015)40 Two-year analysis for Legendre et al's study |
Same as noted above | Same as noted above | Same as noted above | Same as noted above | Same as noted above | Same as noted above | 2 years | -Data were evaluated at three time points, i.e., 26 weeks, 1 year, and 2 years. -In trial 1, statistically significant increase in platelet counts was noted at all three time points. -14/17 patients attained normal platelet count at 26 weeks, and 15/17 attained the same at 1- and 2-year time points -In trial 2, 16/20 patients achieved TMA free event status at week 26 and nearly all patients (19/20) had TMA event-free event status by 2 years. |
Cofiell et al (2015)41 Open-label, nonrandomized, single-group, multi-center trial |
41 patients ≥18 years old |
IC – platelet counts <150×103/L, hemoglobin levels ≤ LLN, LDH levels 1.5× ULN, SCr ≥ULN at screening, ADAMTS13 activity ≥5% or higher and no positive Shiga toxin-producing E. coli test EP – serum, plasma and urine biomarker levels at baseline, 26 and 52 weeks. |
20 | 24 | 35 | 9 | 26 weeks Optional extension phase 1 year |
-After 1 year, patients had reduced U-C5a, U-sC5b-9 levels, renal injury markers (clustering cystatin-c, b2-M, L-FABP-1), markers of inflammation (sTNFR1), markers of coagulation (prothrombin F112 and D-dimer), and endothelial damage (thrombomodulin). -TCA and renal markers were reduced to levels seen in healthy volunteers, but other biomarkers were only reduced to levels compared to pre-treatment. |
Cavero et al (2017)42 Retrospective analysis |
29 patients | IC – patients with secondary aHUS, worsening renal function and persistent TMA despite plasmapheresis. EP – normalization of platelet count and hemoglobin, disappearance of all MAHA markers, improved renal function with a ≥25% reduction of SCr baseline |
8 patients were detected with genetic mutations but only 3 were considered pathogenic. 2 patients had Anti FH auto antibodies |
14 | 24 | 1 | 2–30 weeks Discontinued at 8 weeks on average |
−68% of patients experienced a rapid resolution of the TMA -Only four patients needed dialysis at last follow-up -12/15 patients with drug-induced aHUS, and all patients with postpartum, cancer-related, acute humoral rejection and intestinal lymphangiectasis, responded to eculizumab. -Patients with aHUS secondary to systemic diseases formed a larger part of the cohort that did not respond to treatment with only 2 of 8 patients responding. -Six patients had hematological resolution but no improvement in renal function -Three patients had persistent hematological and renal abnormalities despite eculizumab treatment |
Walle et al (2017)43 Post-hoc analysis of four Phase II prospective studies |
97 Age 1 month-80 years |
IC – documented set of TMA onset symptoms, baseline eGFR of <90 mL/min/1.73 m2 EP – proportion of patients achieving sustained eGFR increase (defined: C15 mL/min/1.73 m2 for C28 days) and platelet count normalization evaluated 1-year post-treatment. |
57 | 43 | 71 | 26 | 1 year | -Patients who received eculizumab ≤7 days after initial presentation of the aHUS showed a significantly (P<0.05) greater improvement in mean eGFR after 1 month -17/21 patients in the group that received eculizumab in ≤7days after presentation had a sustained increase in eGFR after 3 months which remained stable throughout 1 year. -In the group that received eculizumab after >7days, 36/76 had sustained increase in eGFR at1 year. |
Greenbaum et al (2016)44 First prospective trial conducted exclusively in aHUS patients <18 years |
22 19 completed 26 weeks Ages 5 months–17 years |
IC – LDH ≥1.5× ULN, hemoglobin ≤ LLN, fragmented RBCs with a negative Coombs test EP – complete TMA response by 26 weeks |
11 | 11 | 10 | 2 | 26 weeks | −14 patients had achieved a complete TMA response by 26 weeks. -18 patients achieved hematological normalization, and 16 had 25% or better serum creatinine after a median of 55 and 21 days, respectively. -9/11 patients discontinued dialysis -PE/PI was discontinued in all patients. |
Kato et al (2019)31 Interim analysis of the post-marketing surveillance |
33 patients with aHUS 27 patients with secondary TMA |
IC – patients with aHUS diagnosis based on the Japanese diagnostic guide and received at least 1 dose of eculizumab EP – TMA event-free status, complete TMA response, hematologic outcomes, and renal outcomes |
11 of the 18 aHUS patients tested for genetic mutations | 17 | 18 | None | 24 weeks | -Among 29 aHUS patients with available baseline data, platelet count, LDH, and SCr improved in 1 month after beginning eculizumab. -19 patients were TMA event-free, 5 patients had a complete TMA response, 13 patients had platelet normalization, and 16 patients had a decrease in serum creatinine. |
Kumar et al45 Retrospective cohort study |
14 Median age 64 months |
IC –platelet count ≥150×109/L LDH levels <ULN ≥25% decrease in SCr level from baseline on two consecutive measurements obtained ≥4 weeks apart |
NA | 6 | 6 | NA | Patients were followed from January 2012 to January 2018 | −9 days after patients had received eculizumab treatment, 14 had improved hematological response and 13 had improved TMA response. -6 patients, who had required PE/PI, none continued to require further transfusions after eculizumab treatment. - 6 patients who had previously required dialysis, only 1 remained on dialysis after treatment. |
Fakhouri et al46 (2016) Open-label single-arm phase 2 trial | 41 patients Age 18 years or older |
IC – platelet count <150×10(3)/μL, hemoglobin ≤ LLNLDH≥1.5×ULN, and SCr≥ULN EP – complete TMA response |
21 | 24 | 35 | 9 | 26 weeks | -Platelet counts and eGFR increased from baseline in 40 and 22 patients, respectively (P<0.001). -35 patients receiving PE/PI at the beginning, discontinued by week 26. -OF 24 dialysis- dependent patients, five recovered kidney function before starting therapy with eculizumab and 15 of the remaining 19 discontinued dialysis during eculizumab treatment. |
Merill et al47 (2017) Single center, retrospective review |
17 Median patient age at presentation was 46 years, with 76% females |
IC – patients fulfilling aHUS criteria, testing negative for Shiga toxin, with ADAMTS13 levels above 10%, and receiving eculizumab EP – dialysis independence at last follow-up, TMA-event-free status |
11 | 9 | 12 | None | Median duration of eculizumab therapy was 90.5 days Follow-up after cessation of eculizumab was a median 308.5 days |
−94% of all patients had TMA event-free status -82% patients were dialysis-free after last follow-up -Two patients died during eculizumab treatment |
Huerta et al48 (2018) Retrospective study | 22 | IC – women with pregnancy-associated aHUS | 9 | 9 | NA | NA | Median duration of eculizumab treatment – 10 months | −17 patients received PE/PI, but only 3 showed improvement in renal function. -Ten patients received eculizumab and all of them had resolution of TMA - Amongst the remaining 12 patients, six patients needed RRT during follow- up and later-on received renal transplants. |
Abbreviations: TMA, thrombotic microangiopathy; TCA, total complement activity; LDH, lactate dehydrogenase; PE/PI, plasma exchange/plasma infusion; eGFR, estimated glomerular filtration rate; SCr, serum creatinine; ULN, upper limit of normal; LLN, lower limit of normal; NA, data unavailable; sTNFR1, soluble tumor necrosis factor receptor-1; MAHA, microangiopathic hemolytic anemia; aHUS, atypical hemolytic uremic syndrome; FH, factor H.