Table 1.
Category | Type | Assay | Application | Unique features | Status | References |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Population-based | Sanger ‘Standard’ sequencing | Viroseq | Centralized | Genotyping HIV-1 protease gene from codons 1–99 and RT gene from codons 1–335 | Commercially available | [5,6■■] |
Cost 120 USD per sample, VL threshold =2000cpm, Sensitivity >20% | ||||||
Sanger ‘Standard’ sequencing | TruGene | Centralized | Genotyping HIV-1 protease gene from codons 4–99 and RT codons 38–248 | Discontinued | [7] | |
Cost 150 USD per sample, VL threshold = 200cpm | ||||||
Sanger ‘Standard’ sequencing | In-house | Centralized | Genotyping for non-B subtypes and flexible amplification of resistance codons | In development | [5,8–10] | |
Cost 50–150 USD per sample | ||||||
Sensitive | NGS | Illumina | Centralized | Detection of minor variants using unique tagging of individual virion genomes | In development | [11■] |
High number of reads per run, but the read lengths are shorter than 454 | ||||||
NGS | 454 Pyrosequencing | Centralized | Longer read lengths, but limited to 1 million reads, high error rates with polybases >6 | In development | [12] | |
Point mutation assay PCR primer amplification | ASPCR | Point-of-care | Selective amplification of PCR product by match or mismatch of 3’ end of primer | In development | [13] | |
Cost <5 USD per sample, low VL threshold, problems with specificity (polymorphisms) | ||||||
Point mutation assay PCR primer ligation | OLA | Point-of-care | Selective ligation of tagged-oligonucleotides on HIV PCR product by match or mismatch of 3’ end of primer, ligated-oligonucleotides can be identified with ELISA, plate or paper capture detection methods | Currently field testing in Kenya: Clinical trial: NCT01898754 | [14–16] | |
Point mutation assay PCR primer ligation | LRA | Point-of-care | Simplified ligation amplification assay using a one-step single-buffer method and sequence-specific dual-labeled probe for detection | In development | [17,18] |
ASPCR, allele-specific PCR; LRA, one-step ligation on RNA amplification; NGS, next-generation sequencing; OLA, oligonucleotide ligation assay; RT, reverse transcriptase; VL, viral load.