Table 3.
Pros and cons of the identified integrated solutions.
| Role of | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Solution | IoT Device | UAV | Satellite | Sat.Gateway | Pros | Cons |
| Figure 2 | not 5G oriented | 5G-UE | RN | RN (or 5G-gNB) | simpler IoT devices and simpler bent-pipe 5G-agnostic satellites as the ones already available and deployed; 5G-gNBs’ complexity in the terrestrial segment’s nodes, which do not have strict resource constraints. | IoT devices not able to get direct access to the 5G network; more complex UAVs with high energy consumption due to protocol conversion. |
| Figure 3 | not 5G oriented | 5G-UE | RN | RN | simpler IoT devices and simpler bent-pipe 5G-agnostic satellites as the ones already available and deployed; 5G-gNBs’ complexity in the terrestrial segment’s, nodes which do not have strict resource constraints; better management of the 5G cell resources thanks to the 5G-gNB’s location closer to the edge of the network and the lower communication delay between 5G-UE and 5G-gNB. | IoT devices not able to get direct access to the 5G network; more complex UAVs with high energy consumption due to protocol conversion. |
| Figure 4 | not 5G oriented | 5G-UE | 5G-gNB | RN | simpler IoT devices; regenerative satellites able to deploy 5G cells, increasing the reliability and availability of the terrestrial 5G access network. | IoT devices not able to get direct access to the 5G network; more complex UAVs with high energy consumption due to protocol conversion; more complex regenerative satellites with higher energy consumption, still to be designed, built, and launched. |
| Figure 5 | 5G-UE | RN | RN | RN (or 5G-gNB) | simpler and less resource-consuming UAVs and satellites, which can be based on non-5G technologies; 5G-gNBs’ complexity in the terrestrial segment’s nodes, which do not have strict resource constraints. | more complex and resource-consuming IoT devices equipped to get direct access to the 5G-RAN. |
| Figure 6 | 5G-UE | RN | 5G-gNB | RN | simpler and less resource-consuming UAVs; regenerative satellites able to deploy 5G cells, increasing the reliability and availability of the terrestrial 5G access network. | more complex and resource-consuming IoT devices equipped to get direct access to the 5G-RAN; more complex regenerative satellites with higher energy consumption, still to be designed, built, and launched. |
| Figure 7 | 5G-UE | 5G-gNB | RN | RN | UAVs able to deploy 5G cells on-demand for given locations and duration; simpler bent-pipe 5G-agnostic satellites as the ones already available and deployed. | more complex and resource-consuming IoT devices equipped to get direct access to the 5G-RAN; more complex and resource-consuming UAVs. |