TABLE 1.
Bleomycin-induced lung fibrosis in mice [43, 53] | Bleomycin-induced lung fibrosis in rats [43] | Silica-induced lung fibrosis in mice [43] | Chronic allergen-induced lung inflammation and remodelling in mice [54] | Rheumatoid arthritis and lung fibrosis in SKG mice [55] | Skin and lung fibrosis in Fra-2 mice [39] | |||||
Trigger | Chemical: bleomycin | Chemical: bleomycin | Environmental: silica crystals | Allergic: ovalbumin | Immunological: zymosan | Vascular: Fra-2 transgene | ||||
Model characteristics | Epithelial cell injury-induced lung inflammation and fibrosis | Epithelial cell injury-induced lung inflammation and fibrosis | Ongoing epithelial cell injury-induced lung inflammation and progressive fibrosis | AHR, lung inflammation and remodelling with goblet cell hyperplasia, lung fibrosis and ASM hypertrophy | Resembles aspects of arthritic joint inflammation and progressive lung fibrosis | Resembles aspects of skin and progressive lung fibrosis in SSc including microvascular disease and PH | ||||
Treatment# | Preventive | Therapeutic | Preventive | Therapeutic | Preventive | Therapeutic | Chronic | Early | Late | Therapeutic |
days 0–14 | days 7–21; days 7–19 | days 0–21 | days 10–21 | days 0–30 | days 10–30¶ | starting at day 35 for 3 months | weeks 5–11 | weeks 10–16 | weeks 10–16 | |
Effects of nintedanib | Lung fibrosis↓; lung inflammation↓; IL-1β↓; TIMP-1↓; BALF lymphocytes↓ | Lung fibrosis↓; Ashcroft score↓; lung tissue density↓; Cstat↑; lung inflammation↓; lung collagen↓; IL-1β↓; TIMP-1↓; BALF lymphocytes↓; vascularisation↓ | Ashcroft score↓; TGF-β mRNA↓; pro-collagen 1 mRNA↓ | Ashcroft score↓; TGF-β mRNA↓; pro-collagen 1 mRNA↓ | Lung fibrosis↓; lung inflammation↓; lung collagen↓; IL-1β↓; KC↓; TIMP-1↓; BALF neutrophils and lymphocytes↓ | Lung fibrosis↓; lung inflammation↓; lung collagen↓; IL-1β↓; IL-6↓; KC↓; TIMP-1↓; BALF neutrophils and lymphocytes↓ | AHR; total BALF cells↓; OVA-specific IgE↓; IL-4, IL-5, IL-13↓; vascularisation↓; goblet cell hyperplasia↓; ASM area↓; hydroxyproline↓ | Arthritis score↓; lung tissue B220+ B-cells↑; CD103+ dendritic cells↑; monocytes↓; neutrophils↑ | Hydroxyproline↓; BALF lymphocytes and neutrophils↑; lung tissue inflammatory macrophages↑ | Skin and lung myofibroblasts↓; dermal thickness↓; hydroxyproline↓; ECM↓; vessel wall thickness↓; occluded vessels↓; VSMCs↓; MVEC apoptosis↑ |
↓: significant reduction (independent of dose); ↑: significant increase (independent of dose). Fra-2: fos-related antigen-2; AHR: airway hyperreactivity; ASM: airway smooth muscle; SSc: systemic sclerosis; PH: pulmonary hypertension; IL: interleukin; TIMP: tissue inhibitor of matrix metalloproteinase; BALF: bronchoalveolar lavage fluid; Cstat: static lung compliance; TGF: transforming growth factor; KC: chemokine CXCL1/KC; OVA: ovalbumin; ECM: extracellular matrix; VSMC: vascular smooth muscle cell; MVEC: microvascular endothelial cell. #: “preventive” indicates that the administration of nintedanib started simultaneously with the pathogenic trigger and “therapeutic” indicates that the administration of nintedanib began after the onset of substantial fibrosis (the days/weeks listed indicate when nintedanib was administered relative to the pathogenic trigger); ¶: an effect of nintedanib was shown for treatment from day 10 to 30 (treatment only from day 20 to 30 was less effective).