Table 3.
Summary of Results for All Outcome Measures.
| Outcome Measure | Condition |
Time |
Condition × Time |
||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| F | p | F | p | F | p | ||||
| MCP | 9.75 | < .001 | .30 | 1.96 | ns | .08 | 0.74 | ns | .03 |
| Plasma Nicotine | 21.51 | < .001 | .48 | 32.92 | < .001 | .59 | 10.85 | < .001 | .32 |
| HR | 6.95 | < .001 | .23 | 51.02 | < .001 | .69 | 12.36 | < .001 | .35 |
| Systolic BP | 8.44 | < .001 | .27 | 2.44 | ns | .10 | 1.26 | ns | .05 |
| Diastolic BP | 8.87 | < .001 | .28 | 6.42 | < .001 | .22 | 2.41 | < .05 | .10 |
| Subjective Measures | |||||||||
| Hughes-Hatsukamia | |||||||||
| Anxious | 1.55 | ns | .06 | 8.20 | < .001 | .26 | 2.90 | < .05 | .09 |
| Craving | 11.02 | < .001 | .32 | 12.40 | < .001 | .35 | 6.80 | < .001 | .23 |
| Depression | 0.91 | ns | .04 | 0.47 | ns | .02 | 1.59 | ns | .06 |
| Difficulty concentrating | 1.88 | ns | .08 | 2.34 | ns | .09 | 0.73 | ns | .03 |
| Drowsy | 1.18 | ns | .05 | 1.95 | ns | .08 | 1.87 | ns | .08 |
| Hunger | 1.70 | ns | .07 | 5.83 | < .01 | .20 | 1.13 | ns | .05 |
| Impatient | 2.00 | ns | .08 | 6.39 | < .001 | .22 | 1.91 | < .05 | .08 |
| Irritable | 0.48 | ns | .02 | 6.21 | < .01 | .21 | 1.12 | ns | .05 |
| Restless | 2.84 | ns | .11 | 2.97 | < .05* | .11 | 1.39 | ns | .06 |
| Sweets | 0.90 | ns | .04 | 1.30 | ns | .05 | 1.28 | ns | .05 |
| Urge | 7.51 | < .001 | .25 | 17.98 | < .001 | .44 | 3.37 | < .01 | .13 |
| Direct effects of nicotine b | |||||||||
| Confused | 0.18 | ns | .01 | 0.83 | ns | .04 | 1.18 | ns | .06 |
| Dizzy | 2.65 | ns | .12 | 3.41 | < .05* | .15 | 2.15 | ns | .10 |
| Headache | 0.41 | ns | .02 | 0.73 | ns | .04 | 1.17 | ns | .06 |
| Heart pound | 1.05 | ns | .05 | 1.84 | ns | .08 | 1.19 | ns | .06 |
| Light headed | 5.62 | < .01 | .22 | 5.14 | < .01 | .21 | 2.61 | < .05 | .12 |
| Nausea | 1.34 | ns | .06 | 0.12 | ns | .01 | 1.19 | ns | .06 |
| Nervous | 0.19 | ns | .01 | 2.01 | ns | .09 | 0.80 | ns | .04 |
| Salivate | 0.13 | ns | .01 | 1.98 | ns | .09 | 0.48 | ns | .02 |
| Sweaty | 0.22 | ns | .01 | 5.44 | < .01 | .21 | 0.77 | ns | .04 |
| Weak | 1.02 | ns | .05 | 0.34 | .76 | .02 | 0.63 | ns | .03 |
| Direct effects of product use c | |||||||||
| Awake | 15.45 | < .001 | .42 | 6.71 | < .01 | .24 | 1.49 | ns | .07 |
| Calm | 14.86 | < .001 | .41 | 11.43 | < .001 | .35 | 2.26 | < .05 | .10 |
| Concentrate | 11.49 | < .001 | .35 | 0.07 | ns | .00 | 0.54 | ns | .03 |
| Dizzy | 8.16 | < .001 | .28 | 2.76 | ns | .12 | 1.74 | ns | .08 |
| Pleasant | 34.26 | < .001 | .62 | 4.59 | < .05 | .18 | 1.81 | ns | .08 |
| Reduced hunger | 9.54 | < .001 | .31 | 1.20 | ns | .05 | 0.87 | ns | .04 |
| Right now | 0.59 | ns | .03 | 5.70 | < .01 | .21 | 1.81 | ns | .08 |
| Satisfy | 44.20 | < .001 | .68 | 2.54 | ns | .11 | 2.11 | ns | .09 |
| Sick | 1.05 | ns | .05 | 0.23 | ns | .01 | 0.64 | ns | .03 |
| Taste good | 40.48 | < .001 | .66 | 3.87 | < .05 | .16 | 1.96 | ns | .09 |
| Tiffany-Drobesd | |||||||||
| Factor 1 | 9.18 | < .001 | .32 | 16.90 | < .001 | .46 | 8.71 | < .001 | .30 |
| Factor 2 | 2.25 | ns | .10 | 6.31 | < .05 | .24 | 4.40 | < .01 | .18 |
Note.
Hughes and Hatsukami Tobacco Withdrawal Scale,
Direct Effects of Nicotine Use,
Direct Effects of Product Use,
Tiffany-Drobes Questionnaire of Smoking Urges Brief.
Asterisk denotes items that did not have a statistical difference between condition or time points with follow up post-hoc tests.