Skip to main content
. 2019 Sep 20;9:13629. doi: 10.1038/s41598-019-49810-w

Table 2.

Stability evaluation of candidate reference genes during feeding assay of C. partellus fed with purified and crude extracts of bacterially-expressed dsRNA over a period of 5 and 15 days using Normfinder, geNorm and BestKeeper algorithms and deltaCt algorithm.

Purified-dsRNA Bacterially- Induced dsRNA Developmental stages Sex
Algorithm Reference gene 5days of feeding 15 days of feeding 5 days of feeding 15 days of feeding
NormFinder stability Rank stability Rank stability Rank stability Rank stability Rank stability Rank
Actin 0.408 4 0.562 5 0.877 4 1.188 7 2.37145 5 0.617 4
18S 0.395 3 0.464 2 0.932 5 0.762 3 2.999018 6 3.92 6
RPL32 0.808 6 0.529 3 1.072 7 0.87 6 1.955363 4 1.818 5
V-ATPase 0.291 2 0.552 4 0.418 1 0.805 4 0.484509 2 0.379 3
Tubulin 0.449 5 0.836 7 0.516 3 0.51 2 0.425675 1 0.149 1
HSP70 0.977 7 0.807 6 1.534 6 0.827 5 1.736871 2 1.818 5
ELF 0.177 1 0.33 1 0.481 2 0.453 1 1.738245 3 0.272 2
Bestkeeper Actin 1.2 4 0.91 4 0.51 2 1.45 7 3.59 6 2.55 5
18S 1.57 5 0.92 5 1.19 4 0.93 3 5.04 7 5.14 6
RPL32 0.57 1 0.42 2 0.4 1 0.43 1 1.25 1 0.02 1
V-ATPase 1.19 2 0.82 3 0.73 3 1.03 4 2.3 3 0.94 2
Tubulin 1.16 3 1.08 6 1.32 6 1.08 6 2.96 4 1.24 3
HSP70 1.98 6 1.17 7 2.39 7 1.06 5 2.9 5 0.02 1
ELF 1.2 4 0.4 1 1.26 5 0.66 2 2.05 2 2 4
∆CT Actin 0.94 3 1.15 4 1.69 4 1.93 7 3.76 6 2.64 4
18S 0.97 4 1.08 2 1.8 5 1.58 5 5.01 7 5.69 7
RPL32 1.35 6 1.12 3 1.84 6 1.66 6 3.63 5 2.82 5
V-ATPase 0.86 2 1.17 5 1.46 1 1.53 3 2.63 2 2.14 2
Tubulin 0.97 4 1.45 7 1.51 3 1.4 2 2.54 1 2.07 1
HSP70 1.54 7 1.42 6 2.4 7 1.56 4 2.66 3 2.82 5
ELF 0.8 1 1 1 1.5 2 1.31 1 3.46 4 2.25 3
Genorm Actin 0.57 3 0.903 3 2.734 5 1.566 6 2.734 5 1.81 3
18S 0.671 4 0.866 2 3.383 6 1.421 5 3.383 6 2.918 6
RPL32 0.87 5 0.426 1 2.263 4 1.147 3 2.263 4 0.12 1
V-ATPase 0.501 1 0.949 4 1.378 2 0.692 1 1.378 2 0.9 2
Tubulin 0.501 1 1.199 6 0.92 1 1.308 4 0.92 1 1.116 4
HSP70 1.062 6 1.1 5 0.92 1 0.692 1 0.92 1 0.12 1
ELF 0.599 2 0.426 1 2.016 3 0.813 2 2.016 3 1.496 5