Within-species sample pairs included both jasmonic acid-treated and control and both young and mature leaves for the four focal species (Inga cocleensis, Piper cordulatum, Protium panamense, and Psychotria acuminata). Between-species sample pairs include every leaf of each focal species paired with a young, control leaf of a congeneric species, including 14, 10, 2 and 19 species of Inga, Piper, Protium, and Psychotria, respectively. Significance refers to the proportion of 999 differences in chemical similarity between within-species and between-species sample pairs calculated for permuted datasets that were larger than the observed difference.