Skip to main content
. 2019 Sep 20;9(9):e025736. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2018-025736

Table 2.

Quality assessment: included studies

Study Screening Q.1:
Address clearly focused issue
Screening Q.2:
Cohort acceptably recruited
Exposure accurately measured (min. bias) Outcome accurately measured (min. bias) Identified important confounding factors Account for confounding factors in design/ analysis Follow-up complete enough Follow-up long enough Believable results Applicable to local population Fit with available evidence Total Yes Total No Total Can’t tell
Beecham17 (1997) Yes Yes Can’t tell Yes No No Yes Yes Yes Can’t tell Can’t tell 6 2 3
Hallam18 (2006) Yes Yes Yes Yes No No Yes Yes Yes Can’t tell Can’t tell 7 2 2