Alam 1989 BGD.
Methods | CBA study | |
Participants | Number: 623 children (after excluded 27 in intervention group and 50 in control group) Inclusion criteria: HHs with children aged 6–23 months, with > 6 months' observations per year |
|
Interventions | Intervention site (3 subunits): hand pumps were provided with a ratio of 4–6 HHs (3 times more than control) + health education (main objectives: promotion of consistent and exclusive use of hand pump water, improvement of water handling and storage practices, disposal of child's faeces soon after defecation, washing hands before handling food and rubbing hands in ash or using soap after defecation). Control site (2 subunits): no project input. |
|
Outcomes | Incidence of diarrhoea among children aged 6–23 months. Diarrhoea: ≥ 3 loose motions in 24‐hour period whether or not blood was present. An episode was considered new if there was an interval of ≥ 48 hours between symptoms (recall = 7 days). Observed sources of water, faeces visible in the yard, handwashing before food and after defecation |
|
Notes | Location: 5 subunits (paras) in a village in rural Bangladesh Length: 3 years (July 1980 to June 1983) Publication status: journal |
|
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Random sequence generation (selection bias) | High risk | Allocation not random. |
Allocation concealment (selection bias) | High risk | No allocation concealment. |
Blinding of participants and personnel (performance bias) All outcomes | Unclear risk | NA |
Blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias) All outcomes | Unclear risk | NA |
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) All outcomes | Low risk | Similar number of child‐periods excluded in the analysis in both groups (54 vs 55). |
Selective reporting (reporting bias) | Low risk | Report on outcomes prespecified in methods. |
Other bias | Unclear risk | ‐ |
Similarity of baseline outcome measurements | Unclear risk | No mention of baseline risk. |
Similarity of baseline characteristics | Unclear risk | The intervention and control "populations were comparable in terms of education, HH size and sanitation conditions". but no data presented). |
Adequate allocation of intervention concealment during the study | High risk | Quote: "Workers' knowledge of which area was intervention and control." |
Adequate protection against contamination | High risk | Allocation by community – adjacent paras and in the control group some HHs installed hand pumps. Quote: "Over the years of the project some households in the control area purchased their own hand pumps privately." |
Confounders adequately adjusted for in analysis/design | High risk | No analysis adjusting for confounders. |
Recruitment bias | Unclear risk | NA |
Baseline imbalance | Unclear risk | NA |
Loss of clusters | Unclear risk | NA |
Incorrect analysis | Unclear risk | NA |