Aziz 1990 BGD.
Methods | CBA study | |
Participants | Number: exact numbers not presented, on average complete data available for 405 children Inclusion criteria: HHs with children aged < 5 years |
|
Interventions | Intervention (2 villages): 148 new hand pumps (1 pump: 30 people on average) + free maintenance, 92% of HHs received a double pit water sealed latrine, hygiene education emphasising exclusive use of the pump water for all personal and domestic use and the need for all members of the HH, including young children to use the latrines. Control (3 villages): no intervention provided. ORS was given to sick children + referral to hospital if sick. |
|
Outcomes | Diarrhoea incidence, case definition: ≥ 3 loose motions in a 24‐hour period. Recall period 7 days, an episode was considered complete after 2 diarrhoea‐free days. Dysentery incidence, case definition: blood was present in the stools. Persistent diarrhoea incidence, case definition: episodes of duration > 14 days Days of diarrhoea Anthropometry (weight for age, height for age, weight for height) (Hasan 1989; reference is listed under Aziz 1990 BGD)) Hand pump distance and use, defecation of children or disposal of their faeces in latrine (only reported in intervention arm) |
|
Notes | Location: 5 villages in rural Bangladesh Length: 3 years (January 1984 to December 1987) Publication status: journal |
|
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Random sequence generation (selection bias) | High risk | No randomized allocation. |
Allocation concealment (selection bias) | High risk | No allocation concealment. |
Blinding of participants and personnel (performance bias) All outcomes | Unclear risk | NA |
Blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias) All outcomes | Unclear risk | NA |
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) All outcomes | Unclear risk | Total number of children or loss to follow‐up not reported. |
Selective reporting (reporting bias) | Low risk | Report on outcomes prespecified in methods. |
Similarity of baseline outcome measurements | Low risk | Diarrhoea and anthropometry measures were similar at baseline. |
Similarity of baseline characteristics | Unclear risk | Quote: "The two areas were comparable with respect to most sociodemographic and economic characteristics although the control area was slightly better off in terms of female education and socio‐economic level." Comment: however, no data presented. |
Adequate allocation of intervention concealment during the study | High risk | Quote: "Project staff and the community under investigation knew that the aim of the study was to decrease the diarrhoea incidence." |
Adequate protection against contamination | Low risk | The 2 areas were 5 km apart. |
Confounders adequately adjusted for in analysis/design | High risk | No adjustments in the analysis. |
Recruitment bias | Unclear risk | NA |
Baseline imbalance | Unclear risk | NA |
Loss of clusters | Unclear risk | NA |
Incorrect analysis | Unclear risk | NA |