Table 1.
First author | Study design | Methenamine dose and duration | Number of patients | Mean age in years (range) | Incidence of UTI or bacteriuria (methenamine versus placebo, when applicable) | Renal function of patients |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Recurrent UTI | ||||||
Freeman6 | Randomized Controlled Trial | Methenamine mandelate 1 g QID × 25 months | 122 | (20–89) with 58% >60 years | 25% versus 86% | Patients excluded if CrCl <41 ml/min |
Freeman7 | Randomized Controlled Trial | Methenamine mandelate 1 g QID × 2 years | 249 | 59 (21–83) | 9% versus 40% (p < 0.001) | 6% of patients had renal failure$ |
Bohensky8 | Case Series | Methenamine mandelate 2 g QID × 25 days | 90 | 81.5 (67–102) | 28%* | NR |
Parvio9 | Case Series | Methenamine hippurate 1 g BID × 6 months | 52 | 84.7 (65–96) | 42.5%* | NR |
McAllister10 | Case Reports | Methenamine hippurate 500 mg BID | 4 | 89 | Not applicable | Various‡ |
Genitourinary Surgical Procedures | ||||||
Schiotz11 | Randomized Controlled Trial | Methenamine hippurate 1 g BID × 5 days | 145 | 58.3 (30–87) | 2.7% versus 13.9% (p = 0.03) | NR |
Tyreman12 | Randomized Controlled Trial | Methenamine hippurate 1 g night before surgery, 1 g BID day of surgery, 1 g TID × 5 days after surgery | 109 | 65 (63–67) | 2.2% versus 28.6% (p < 0.001) | NR |
Wesolowski13 | Randomized Controlled Trial | Methenamine mandelate 3–4 g daily | 75 | 67 (54–80) | 40% versus 66.6% | NR |
Long-term Catheterization | ||||||
Kostiala14 | Randomized Controlled Trial | Methenamine hippurate 1 g BID + 0.5 g ascorbic acid TID × 8 days | 123 | 75 | 39% versus 100% at 1 week 77% versus 100% at 2 weeks Both 100% at 6 weeks |
Patients excluded if SCr >1.5 mg/dl |
Norrman15 | Prospective Cohort Study | Methenamine hippurate 1 g BID × 4 months | 22 | 75 (70–80) | 18.2% versus 77.3% | NR |
Methenamine only.
Defined as SCr >2 mg/100 ml.
One patient had a CrCl of 37 ml/min, one had a CrCl of 43 ml/min, one had ESRD with a CrCl of 8 ml/min, one not reported.
BID, twice daily; NR, not reported; QID, four times daily; SCr, serum creatinine; TID, three times daily; UTI urinary tract infection.