Skip to main content
. 2019 Sep 5;19(18):3835. doi: 10.3390/s19183835

Table 1.

Comparison of advantages and disadvantages of related work.

Method Key Feature Advantages Disadvantages
Distributed clustering with data fusion [10,11] Multi-hop and intra-cluster communication The need for centralized stations for cluster CH formation is eliminated Selfishness of nodes is ignored.
Cognitive radio WSN (CR-WSN) [12,13,14,15] Utilization of increased spectrum Extends WSNs lifetime Clustering in CR-WSNs has not yet been matured.
Energy conservation via efficient routing algorithms like LEACH, LEACH-C [16], PEGASIS [17,18] Nodes of clusters made rich in information about neighboring nodes Extend WSNs’ lifetime Selfishness of the node is ignored.
One Hop Cluster-Head Algorithm (OHCH) [19]. CH selection Prolonging the network lifetime and reducing the network data latency Ignoring the distance factor as nodes get away and deplete energy quickly
Dynamic network state learning model (NSLM) [20] Hidden Markov model (HMM) and Lagrange multiplier-based approach Outperformed in terms of buffer cost, holding cost, overflow, energy consumption, and bandwidth usage Other optimization approaches are ignored to compare.
Noncooperative game theoretic approach in clustering [22] Dependability assessment mechanism for heterogeneous WSNs Reliability and availability measures for susceptible sensor nodes improved Not all possible security measures considered.
Coalitional game theory [24] Based on topological structure Extend WSNs’ lifetime via finding the cheapest route How to choose corresponding leaders is not mentioned in the work.
Bayesian game [25] Bayesian game to form static game Extend WSNs’ lifetime Imperfect information.
Game theory [28] A trade-off between energy conservation and network throughput, double-time Nash equilibrium Balances energy consumption Selfishness of nodes are ignored.
Game theory-based energy efficient clustering routing protocol (GEEC) [30] The proposed mechanism is compared with LEACH and LEACH-C Extend WSNs’ lifetime No guarantee of the connectivity and robustness of the network.
An evolutionary game [31] Combined the evolutionary game with the classical GT. Extend WSNs’ lifetime and provides a better delivery ratio. Selfishness of nodes are ignored.