Skip to main content
. 2015 Feb 25;2015(2):CD007897. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007897.pub3

1. Grading of the evidence.

Comparison Outcome Risk of bias Inconsistency Indirectness Imprecision Publication bias Quality of the evidence
House remediation versus no remediation
 Adults Asthma‐related symptoms 2 RCTs (low risk of bias) and 1 CBA study (high risk of bias) Inconsistent results between the high risk of bias study and the low risk of bias studies Moderate‐quality evidence
  Asthma medication 1 RCT (low risk of bias) Perceived change in medication inconsistent with the reported use of medication Moderate‐quality evidence
  Respiratory infections 2 RCTs (low risk of bias) and 1 CBA study (high risk of bias) Wide CIs in the high risk of bias study Moderate‐quality evidence
Completed house remediation versus remediation in progress
 Adults Asthma‐related symptoms 1 CBA study (high risk of bias)   Very low‐quality evidence
Office building remediation versus no exposure
 Adults Asthma‐related symptoms 1 CBA study (high risk of bias) Very low‐quality evidence
  Respiratory symptoms 1 CBA study (high risk of bias) Very low‐quality evidence
House remediation versus information
 Children Asthma‐related symptoms 1 cRCT (low risk of bias) In a mixed model a significant decrease at 10‐month follow‐up Moderate‐quality evidence
  Number of acute care visits 1 cRCT (low risk of bias) A significant decrease only 6 to 12 months after remediation Moderate‐quality evidence
House remediation versus no remediation
 Children Asthma‐related symptoms 1 CBA study (high risk of bias) ? Very low‐quality evidence
  Respiratory symptoms 1 CBA study (high risk of bias) ?   Very low‐quality evidence
School remediation versus no exposure
 Children Asthma‐related symptoms 2 CBA study (high risk of bias) Wide CIs Very low‐quality evidence
  Respiratory infections 1 CBA study (high risk of bias) Very low‐quality evidence
  Respiratory symptoms 2 CBA study (high risk of bias) Very low‐quality evidence
School remediation versus no exposure
 Adults Asthma‐related symptoms 2 CBA studies (high risk of bias) Inconsistent results Wide CIs Very low‐quality evidence
  Respiratory infections 1 CBA study (high risk of bias) No control group data Very low‐quality evidence
  Respiratory symptoms 2 CBA studies (high risk of bias) Inconsistent results Wide CIs Very low‐quality evidence

CI = confidence interval
 RCT = randomised controlled trial
 CBA = controlled before‐after study
 cRCT = cluster‐randomised controlled trial