Skip to main content
. 2019 Sep 24;9(9):e031767. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2019-031767

Table 1.

Description of the multistep development process

Establishment of the Working Group Generation of the initial checklist Optimisation of the checklist Approval of the final checklist
Initial assessment of adapted guidelines Semistructured interviews Delphi consensus survey External review by guideline developers External review by guideline users Final assessment of adapted guidelines
Main objective To identify individuals who are relevant to participate in the project To develop the initial version of the checklist To assess the adequacy of each item of the checklist To explore current practices in adaptation of guidelines To define the list of items to be included in the checklist To assess the usefulness of each item of the checklist To assess the usefulness of each item of the checklist To assess the adequacy of each item of the checklist To approve the final version of the checklist
Study design Methodological survey of adapted guidelines Semistructured interviews Delphi consensus survey Survey Semistructured interviews Methodological survey of adapted guidelines
Participants
  • Coordination Team

  • Advisory Group

  • Delphi Panel Members

  • Coordination Team

  • Advisory Group

Coordination Team (two reviewers) Guideline developers Delphi Panel Members Guideline developers Guideline users Coordination Team (two reviewers)
  • Coordination Team

  • Advisory Group

Main outcome Applicability rating of each item of the checklist Participants’ views and experiences with process for adapting guidelines Items considered relevant to report the adaptation of guidelines Usefulness rating of each item of the checklist Participants’ views and experiences with the checklist Applicability rating of each item of the checklist
Study size Convenience sample Convenience sample of 10 adapted guidelines Sampling saturation 20–30 participants from GIN Adaptation Guidelines Working Group, WHO and authors of adapted guidelines GIN community Sampling saturation Convenience sample of 10 adapted guidelines

GIN, Guidelines International Network.