Table 2.
Summary of studies evaluating RRT-related interventions for HIRRT in critically ill patients.
Study | Design | Intervention(s) | Occurrence of HIRRT | Significance |
---|---|---|---|---|
Intermittent hemodialysis | ||||
Lynch [82] |
Retrospective cohort N = 191 patients; 892 sessions |
Dialysate sodium profiling |
Case: 36/242 = 14.9% Control: 59/650 = 9.1% |
NS |
du Cheyron [83] |
RCT N = 74 patients; 574 sessions |
Blood volume and temperature control |
BVM: 33/190 = 17.4% BVM + BTM: 30/194 = 15.5% Control: 32/188 = 17.0% |
NS |
du Cheyron et al. [57] |
Prospective cohort N = 62 patients; 572 sessions |
Blood volume and temperature control |
Case: 41/189 = 21.7% Control: 110/383 = 28.7% |
P = 0.09 |
Schortgen et al. [5] |
Retrospective cohort N = 121 patients; 537 sessions |
Multimodal approach |
Case: 176/289 = 60.9% Control: 176/248 = 71.0% |
P = 0.015 |
Paganini et al. [34] |
Randomized cross-over study N = 10 patients; 60 sessions |
Variable dialysate sodium and UF profiling |
Case: 16.0% Control: 45.5% |
Not reported |
Jardin et al. [41] |
Prospective cohort N = 8 patients; 53 sessions |
17.5% albumin priming vs saline | Albumin: stable MAP and more UF (530 mL/h vs 366 mL/h) |
MAP: P < 0.001 Not reported for UF |
Sustained low-efficiency dialysis | ||||
Edrees et al. [58] |
Randomized cross-over study N = 21 patients; 78 sessions |
Lower dialysate temperature (35 °C vs 37 °C) |
Case: 0.7 ± 0.7 Control: 1.5 ± 1.1 |
P < 0.0001 |
Albino [84] |
RCT N = 75 patients; 195 sessions |
Duration of RRT: 6 h vs 10 h |
6 h: 63/100 = 63.0% 10 h: 53/95 = 55.8% |
NS |
Lima et al. [33] |
RCT N = 39 patients; 62 sessions |
Lower dialysate temperature with dialysate sodium and UF profiling |
Case: 8/34 = 23.5% Control: 16/28 = 57.1% |
P = 0.009 |
Continuous renal replacement therapy | ||||
Robert et al. [60] |
Randomized cross-over study N = 30 patients |
Lower heating device temperature (36 °C vs 38 °C) | Less interventions for HIRRT with cooler temperature | P = 0.08 |
Eastwood et al. [46] |
Prospective cohort N = 21 patients; 41 RRT starts |
CRRT pump speed | No HIRRT reported at CRRT initiation | Not applicable |
Rokyta et al. [59] |
Prospective cohort N = 9 patients |
CRRT-induced cooling (SF and RB warmed to 37 °C vs no warming) | MAP and SVR increased with cooling | P < 0.05 |
Adapted from Douvris et al. [9] under the terms and conditions of a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/)
BVM blood volume monitoring, BTM blood temperature monitoring, CRRT continuous renal replacement therapy, HIRRT hemodynamic instability related to renal replacement therapy, MAP mean arterial pressure, RCT randomized controlled trial, SF substitution fluid, RB returned blood, UF ultrafiltration