Table 2.

Outcomes after transplantation from SPD kidneys: ranked by n = x

Author	Date range	n = x	Definition of SPD	Outcome – graft survival	Comments
Dharnidharka [9]	1987–2003	3957	0–5 years	1-year graft survival	EBK GT rate 4% SOK GT rate 3%
				▪ SOK – 81% ▪ EBK – 85%
				3-year graft survival
				▪ SOK – 68% ▪ EBK – 76%
				5-year graft survival
				▪ SOK – 63% ▪ EBK – 71%
Bhayana [10]	1998–2006	3198	0–5 years	1-year graft survival	EBK GT rate 5% SOK GT rate 3%
				▪ SOK – 81% ▪ EBK – 85% ▪ Adult SCD – 90% ▪ Adult ECD – 83%
				10-year graft survival
				▪ SOK – 53% ▪ EBK – 64% ▪ Adult SCD – 57% ▪ Adult ECD – 40%
Pelletier [11]	1993–2002	2449	< 20 kg	5-year graft survival	HR 0.96 for GL per 1 kg increase in donor weight
				▪ SOK – 55% ▪ EBK – 73%
Bresnahan [12]	1988–1995	2198	0–5 years	1-year graft survival	SOK + EBK GT rate 10%
				▪ SOK + EBK – 74%
				5-year graft survival
				▪ SOK + EBK – 56%
Maluf [13]	2005–2010	1531	< 20 kg	1-year graft survival	1-year transplant outcomes by kg weight strata
				▪ SOK – 69% (8 Kg) ▪ EBK – 80% (8 Kg) ▪ SOK – 86% (20 Kg) ▪ EBK – 91% (20 Kg)
Chesnaye [14]	1990–2013	429	0–5 years	5-year graft survival	Association of donor-recipient age combination on outcomes
				▪ 70% (recipient age 0–3 years) ▪ 75% (recipient age 0–5 years) ▪ 81% (recipient age 6–11 years) ▪ 83% (recipient age 12–19 years)
Yaffe [15]	1996–2013	167	10–20 kg	1-year graft survival	All into paediatric recipients
				▪ SOK – 90% ▪ EBK – 86%
				5-year graft survival
				▪ SOK – 61% ▪ EBK – 73%
Winnicki [16]	2000–2013	126	Not defined	1-year graft survival	All into paediatric recipients
				▪ EBK – 86% ▪ Adult SCD – 93%
				5-year graft survival
				▪ EBK – 64% ▪ Adult SCD – 69%
Diaz [17]	1990–2012	100	Not defined	12-year graft survival	GT rate 15%
				▪ EBK – 79% ▪ Adult SCD – 69%
Satterthwaite [18]	1984–1995	91	1–4 years	1-year graft survival
				▪ SOK – 64% ▪ EBK – 82%
Thomusch [19]	1989–2008	78	Not defined	1-year graft survival
				▪ EBK – 83% ▪ Adult SCD – 90%
				5-year graft survival
				▪ EBK – 76% ▪ Adult SCD – 78%
				10-year graft survival
				▪ EBK – 74% ▪ Adult SCD – 56%
Sureshkumar [20]	1990–2001	72	Not defined	1-year graft survival	GT rate 13% - Mean age 17 months
				▪ EBK – 82% ▪ Adult LD – 93%
Gander [21]	2000–2015	60	0–6 years	1-year graft survival
				▪ All SPD organs – 1 year. GS 81%
				5-year graft survival
				▪ All SPD organs – 5 years. GS 70%
Strey [22]	1992–1999	56	0.50.5–48 months	1-year graft survival	GT rate 21% - donors < 1 years age (heparinisation used)
				▪ EBK – 78% ▪ Adult DD – 92%
Sharma [23]	2000–2011	52	< 10 years old	5-year graft survival	All into adult recipients
				▪ SOK – 81% ▪ EBK – 94% ▪ Adult SCD – 75% ▪ Adult ECD – 75%
Borboroglu [24]	1994–2001	48	0–2 years	2-year graft survival
				▪ SOK – 93% ▪ EBK – 77%
Dave [5]	1997–2011	47	< 2 years	1-year graft survival	No difference compared to older paediatric donors. Median 9 years. PS 100%
				▪ SOK + EBK – 83%
Bretan [25]	1993–1996	40	0–5 years	1-year graft survival	GT rate 2.5%
				▪ EBK – 100%
				2-year graft survival
				▪ EBK – 85%
Sui [26]	2012–2014	38	< 15 kg	1-year graft survival	All into paediatric recipients
				▪ All SPD organs – 89% ▪ SOK – 96% ▪ EBK – 70%
Basiri [27]	2006–2013	36	Not defined	1-year graft survival	GT rate 5.5%
				▪ EBK + SOK – 90% ▪ Adult DD – 92%
Hobart [28]	1990–1997	33	< 4 years	1-year graft survival	GT rate 15%
				▪ EBK – 87% ▪ Adult DD – 84%
Mohanka [29]	2002–2006	33	< 15 kg	1-year graft survival	All into adult recipients
				▪ SOK – 86% ▪ EBK – 79%
Salvatierra [30]	1969–1973	32	1–9 years	6-month graft survival
				▪ SOK – 50%
Zafarghandi [31]	2004–2009	23	< 16 years	1-year graft survival	All into adult recipients
				▪ EBK + SOK – 96% ▪ Adult DD – 91%
				5-year graft survival
				▪ EBK + SOK – 85% ▪ Adult DD – 85%

GS graft survival, GT graft thrombosis, HR hazard ratio, GL graft loss, LD live donor, DD deceased donor, SOK single organ kidney, EBK en bloc kidney, PS patient survival