Skip to main content
. 2019 Nov;109(11):e13–e20. doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2019.305278

TABLE 1—

Characteristics of the Studies Included in the Meta-Analysis of Effects of Shift Work Exposure on Mental Health and Male-Female Differences: United States, 2018

Study Design Follow-Up Type of Adverse Mental Health Outcome Tool Used Case Definition Sample Size Age, Yearsa Gender Occupational Group
Lin et al.14 Cohort study 1 y General poor mental health symptoms GHQ-12 Score > 4 1360 29.9 (20–45) Female Nurses
Bara and Arber15 Cohort study 8 y General poor mental health symptoms GHQ-12 Score > 4 9765 21–73 Female and male Not specified
Bildt and Michelsen17 Cohort study 4 y General poor mental health symptoms GHQ-12 Score > 75th percentile 420 46–63 Female and male Not specified
Driesen et al.27 Cohort study 10 y Depressive symptoms Self-report HPQ checklist Current/past treatment of depressive disorder 8178 40.1 (8.0) Female and male Not specified
De Raeve et al.28 Cohort study 2 y General poor mental health symptoms GHQ-12 Score > 4 6828 41.72 (8.70) Female and male Not specified
Berthelsen et al.29 Cohort study 1 y Anxiety and depressive symptoms HADS-14 Score > 8 in respective scales 1582 30 (21–60) Female and male Nurses
Poole et al. 30 Cohort study 6 mo Anxiety and depressive symptoms GHQ-28 anxiety and depression scales Score > 4 in respective scales 298 35 (18–60) Female and male Factory employees

Note. GHQ = General Health Questionnaire; HADS = Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale; HPQ = Health and Work Performance Questionnaire.

a

Average age at baseline, or the highest mean when the study presented the population in stratified groups, with SD or range presented in parentheses.