Skip to main content
. 2019 Aug 19;9(10):3381–3393. doi: 10.1534/g3.119.400336

Table 1. Average Pearson’s correlation (APC), mean arctan absolute percentage error (MAAPE) and their standard deviation (SD) for each trait (grain yield, GY, Plant height, PH, anthesis silking interval, ASI, days to heading, DTHD, plant height, PTHT, days to maturity, DTMT) and each maize and wheat dataset under study for three models, BMTME, BMORS and UT.

Dataset Model Trait APC SD MAAPE SD
Maize dataset 1 BMORS ASI 0.4263 0.0569 0.4024 0.0261
Maize dataset 1 BMORS GY 0.3449 0.0391 0.1142 0.0055
Maize dataset 1 BMORS PH 0.4683 0.0279 0.0395 0.0013
Maize dataset 1 BMTME ASI 0.4338 0.0509 0.3944 0.0228
Maize dataset 1 BMTME GY 0.3504 0.043 0.1112 0.0051
Maize dataset 1 BMTME PH 0.4502 0.0366 0.0392 0.0013
Maize dataset 1 UT ASI 0.4281 0.0525 0.3918 0.0226
Maize dataset 1 UT GY 0.3522 0.0368 0.1095 0.0054
Maize dataset 1 UT PH 0.4787 0.0281 0.0385 0.0013
Wheat dataset 2 BMORS DTHD 0.8533 0.0378 0.5625 0.0253
Wheat dataset 2 BMORS PTHT 0.4657 0.0434 0.6023 0.0234
Wheat dataset 2 BMTME DTHD 0.8716 0.0287 0.4633 0.0234
Wheat dataset 2 BMTME PTHT 0.4782 0.0419 0.6013 0.0203
Wheat dataset 2 UT DTHD 0.8557 0.0368 0.5405 0.0252
Wheat dataset 2 UT PTHT 0.4617 0.044 0.5935 0.0228
Wheat Iranian dataset 3 BMORS DTHD 0.5862 0.0166 0.0392 4.00E-04
Wheat Iranian dataset 3 BMORS DTMT 0.4288 0.0224 0.0605 8.00E-04
Wheat Iranian dataset 3 BMTME DTHD 0.5918 0.0155 0.0389 5.00E-04
Wheat Iranian dataset 3 BMTME DTMT 0.5182 0.0217 0.056 8.00E-04
Wheat Iranian dataset 3 UT DTHD 0.5863 0.0173 0.0393 4.00E-04
Wheat Iranian dataset 3 UT DTMT 0.4854 0.0208 0.0569 8.00E-04
EYT dataset 4 BMORS DTHD 0.8149 0.0105 0.0356 0.001
EYT dataset 4 BMORS DTMT 0.7768 0.0131 0.023 6.00E-04
EYT dataset 4 BMORS GY 0.4444 0.0224 0.0736 0.0021
EYT dataset 4 BMORS Height 0.5455 0.0207 0.0381 7.00E-04
EYT dataset 4 BMTME DTHD 0.8363 0.0075 0.0303 6.00E-04
EYT dataset 4 BMTME DTMT 0.7973 0.012 0.0212 5.00E-04
EYT dataset 4 BMTME GY 0.4311 0.0234 0.0734 0.0021
EYT dataset 4 BMTME Height 0.5728 0.0156 0.0374 8.00E-04
EYT dataset 4 UT DTHD 0.8161 0.0101 0.0341 8.00E-04
EYT dataset 4 UT DTMT 0.7726 0.013 0.0228 5.00E-04
EYT dataset 4 UT GY 0.4551 0.0231 0.0713 0.0018
EYT dataset 4 UT Height 0.5483 0.0182 0.0378 7.00E-04
EYT dataset 5 BMORS DTHD 0.8519 0.0154 0.0241 8.00E-04
EYT dataset 5 BMORS DTMT 0.7928 0.0165 0.016 6.00E-04
EYT dataset 5 BMORS GY 0.5589 0.0269 0.0694 0.0019
EYT dataset 5 BMORS Height 0.5563 0.0232 0.0349 0.001
EYT dataset 5 BMTME DTHD 0.8596 0.0132 0.0217 6.00E-04
EYT dataset 5 BMTME DTMT 0.8112 0.0153 0.0149 6.00E-04
EYT dataset 5 BMTME GY 0.5486 0.0257 0.0698 0.0019
EYT dataset 5 BMTME Height 0.563 0.0244 0.0348 0.0011
EYT dataset 5 UT DTHD 0.8519 0.0152 0.0237 7.00E-04
EYT dataset 5 UT DTMT 0.7902 0.0159 0.016 6.00E-04
EYT dataset 5 UT GY 0.5621 0.0271 0.0684 0.002
EYT dataset 5 UT Height 0.5591 0.0244 0.0346 0.001
EYT dataset 6 BMORS DTHD 0.8416 0.0104 0.0203 6.00E-04
EYT dataset 6 BMORS DTMT 0.7292 0.0128 0.0161 3.00E-04
EYT dataset 6 BMORS GY 0.4855 0.0206 0.0779 0.0025
EYT dataset 6 BMORS Height 0.5093 0.0198 0.0434 9.00E-04
EYT dataset 6 BMTME DTHD 0.8278 0.0095 0.0204 7.00E-04
EYT dataset 6 BMTME DTMT 0.7525 0.0116 0.0151 3.00E-04
EYT dataset 6 BMTME GY 0.5043 0.0195 0.0755 0.0022
EYT dataset 6 BMTME Height 0.5077 0.0232 0.0425 8.00E-04
EYT dataset 6 UT DTHD 0.8425 0.0101 0.0201 6.00E-04
EYT dataset 6 UT DTMT 0.731 0.0127 0.016 3.00E-04
EYT dataset 6 UT GY 0.489 0.0183 0.0774 0.0023
EYT dataset 6 UT Height 0.514 0.0187 0.0424 9.00E-04
EYT dataset 7 BMORS DTHD 0.8406 0.0098 0.0314 6.00E-04
EYT dataset 7 BMORS DTMT 0.8576 0.0082 0.0174 4.00E-04
EYT dataset 7 BMORS GY 0.512 0.0226 0.0686 0.0016
EYT dataset 7 BMORS Height 0.3994 0.0258 0.048 0.0013
EYT dataset 7 BMTME DTHD 0.8549 0.0092 0.0291 8.00E-04
EYT dataset 7 BMTME DTMT 0.8674 0.0083 0.0163 5.00E-04
EYT dataset 7 BMTME GY 0.468 0.0274 0.0714 0.0014
EYT dataset 7 BMTME Height 0.4306 0.0276 0.0468 0.0014
EYT dataset 7 UT DTHD 0.8403 0.0097 0.0307 7.00E-04
EYT dataset 7 UT DTMT 0.8582 0.0079 0.0172 5.00E-04
EYT dataset 7 UT GY 0.5132 0.024 0.0684 0.0016
EYT dataset 7 UT Height 0.4006 0.0263 0.0468 0.0014