Table 1. Quality items included for quality assessment, source from which the quality item was obtained, and number of publications that had a positive quality score, per quality item.
Item code | Source | Quality item |
A | Delphi list | Was a method of randomization used? |
B | Added by authors† | Was the period of outcome measurements equal among all groups? |
C | Considered for Delphi list | Is it unlikely that compliance may explain differences between groups? |
D | Added by authors | Are side effects reported? |
E | Delphi list‡ | Were inclusion criteria specified? |
F | Delphi list‡ | Were exclusion criteria specified? |
G | Considered for Delphi list | Are the interventions described explicitly? |
H | Delphi list | Were the groups similar at baseline regarding the most important prognostic indicators? |
I | Delphi list | Was the patient masked to the treatment? |
G | Considered for Delphi list | Was calculation of statistical power reported after allocation to the treatment? |
K | Delphi list | Was an intention-to-treat analysis performed? |
L | Delphi list | Was the treatment allocation concealed? |
M | Delphi list | Was the outcome assessor blinded? |
N | Delphi list | Was the care provider blinded? |
The authors added items to improve interpretations of liver cirrhosis measurements.
Item split into inclusion and exclusion criteria.