Table 3. Risk of bias of included trials.
StudyRef | Design | Publication type | Withdrawals and dropouts | Quality score | Quality criteria not fulfilled |
Salama et al.29 | RCT | Article | No | 10 | i, l, m, n |
Lyra et al.14 | RCT | Article | No | 10 | i, l, m, n |
Amer et al.16 | Case-control | Article | No | 9 | a, i, l, m, n |
Peng et al.15 | Case-control | Article | No | 9 | a, i, l, m, n |
El-Ansary et al.30 | Case-control | Article | No | 9 | a, i, l, m, n |
Mohamadnejad et al.32 | RCT | Article | No | 12 | m, n |
Liao et al.31 | Case-control | Article | No | 9 | a, i, l, m, n |
Xu et al.17 | RCT | Article | No | 12 | m, n |
Bai et al.34 | Case-control | Article | No | 9 | a, i, l, m, n |
Liu et al.33 | RCT | Article | No | 10 | i, l, m, n |
Salama et al.35 | RCT | Article | No | 10 | i, l, m, n |
Al Tayeb et al.36 | Case-control | Article | No | 9 | a, i, l, m, n |
Suk et al.38 | RCT | Article | No | 10 | i, l, m, n |
Mohamadnejad et al.37 | RCT | Article | No | 14 | No* |
Wu et al.39 | RCT | Article | No | 10 | i, l, m, n |
No*, the study got 14 “Yes” in the risk test.
Abbreviation: RCT, randomized controlled trial.