Table 4.
Preoperative and postoperative clinical and functional mean scores per study and other variables.
| Authors [ref] | Preoperative Mean Scores | Postoperatives Mean Scores | Other Variables |
|---|---|---|---|
| De Boer et al16 | N/A | N/A | On U/S post-operative exam (mean 30 months) 10(40%) of the repaired tendons were still sufficient |
| Clark et al.7 | VAS Repair-Group: 7,5 | VAS Repair-Group: 1,4 | N/A |
| VAS No Repair-Group: 8,2 | VAS No Repair-Group: 2,5 | ||
| Active FF in No Repair-Group 20 | FF Repair-Group: 112 | ||
| degrees less than Repair-Group | FF No Repair-Group: 94 | ||
| Werner et al.17 | ASES Repair-Group: 37,9 | ASES Improvement Repair-Group: 35,8 | Subscapularis repair and lateralized glenosphere in isolation had no effect on ASES, but in combination ASES was significantly less improved |
| ASES No Repair-Group: 36,6 | ASES Improvement No Repair-Group: 38 | ||
| Vourazeris et al.6 | N/A | SPADI Repair-Group: 23,4 | N/A |
| SPADI No Repair-Group: 23,2 | |||
| ASES Repair-Group: 77,7 | |||
| ASES No Repair-Group: 79,3 | |||
| UCLA Repair-Group: 28,3 | |||
| UCLA No Repair-Group: 28,8 | |||
| SST Repair-Group: 9,2 | |||
| SST No Repair-Group: 9,1 | |||
| Constant Repair-Group:72,6 | |||
| Constant No Repair-Group: 72,9 | |||
| FF Repair-Group: 120 | |||
| FF No Repair-Group: 122 | |||
| External Rotation Repair-Group: 24 | |||
| External Rotation No Repair-Group: 26 | |||
| ABD Repair-Group: 109 | |||
| ABD No Repair-Group:112 | |||
| ER Strength Repair-Group: 9,9lb | |||
| ER Strength No Repair-Group: 9,9 lb | |||
| Friedman et al.18 | SPADI Repair-Group: 80,2 | SPADI Repair-Group: 15,9 | N/A |
| SPADI No Repair-Group: 84,6 | SPADI No Repair-Group: 23,5 | ||
| ASES Repair-Group: 38,8 | ASES Repair-Group: 86,7 | ||
| ASES No Repair-Group: 34,9 | ASES No Repair-Group: 82,1 | ||
| UCLA Repair-Group: 13,7 | UCLA Repair-Group: 30,2 | ||
| UCLA No Repair-Group: 12,7 | UCLA No Repair-Group: 29,7 | ||
| SST Repair-Group: 3,4 | SST Repair-Group: 10,5 | ||
| SST No Repair-Group: 3,3 | SST No Repair-Group: 9,6 | ||
| Constant Repair-Group:34,8 | Constant Repair-Group:72,9 | ||
| Constant No Repair-Group:33,8 | Constant No Repair-Group:67,9 | ||
| Active ff Repair-Group: 91 | Active ff Repair-Group: 141 | ||
| Active ff No Repair-Group: 85 | Active ff No Repair-Group: 137 | ||
| Active ABD Repair-Group: 67 | Active ABD Repair-Group: 107 | ||
| Active ABD No Repair-Group: 75 | Active ABD No Repair-Group: 119 | ||
| IR Score Repair-Group: 3,3 | IR Score Repair-Group: 5,1 | ||
| IR Score No Repair-Group: 3.2 | IR Score No Repair-Group: 4,4 | ||
| Active ER Repair-Group: 13 | Active ER Repair-Group: 34 | ||
| Active ER No Repair-Group: 20 | Active ER No Repair-Group: 35 | ||
| Passive ER Repair-Group: 23 | Passive ER Repair-Group: 45 | ||
| Passive ER No Repair-Group: 31 | Passive ER No Repair-Group: 50 | ||
| Strength Repair-Group:0,6kg | Strength Repair-Group: 3,9kg | ||
| Strength No Repair-Group:0,5 kg | Strength No Repair-Group: 2,9 kg |
N/A: not applicable, VAS: Visual Analogue Scale, SPADI: Shoulder Pain and Disability Index, ASES, American Shoulder and Elbow Score, UCLA Score: University of California at Los Angeles Score, SST: Simple Shoulder Test, ABD: abduction, ADD: adduction, FF: forward flexion, ER: external rotation, IR: internal rotation, U/S: ultrasound.