Table 1.
Year | Authors | Sample | Reward region Method Stimulus | Result in mothers with PPD (relative to healthy mothersunless otherwise noted) |
---|---|---|---|---|
2007 | Silverman et al. | PPD women 6–8 weeks postpartum Healthy women 6–8 weeks postpartum |
Striatum fMRI Positive words |
↓ activation |
2011 | Moses-Kolko et al. | PPD women <10 weeks postpartum Healthy women <10 weeks postpartum |
Striatum fMRI Monetary reward task |
= Initial activation but ↑ attenuation to baseline |
2012 | Moses-Kolko et al. | PPD women early postpartum Healthy women early postpartum Non-postpartum depressed Non-postpartum healthy |
Striatum PET | ↓ D2/3 receptor binding with postpartum state but no differences between depressed and healthy postpartum women |
2012 | Laurent and Ablow | Depressed mothers 18 months postpartum Non-depressed mothers 18 months postpartum |
NAc, striatum, OFC fMRIOwn infant cry |
↓ Activation |
2013 | Laurent and Ablow | Depressed mothers 18 months postpartum Non-depressed 18 months postpartum |
Striatum, OFC fMRI Own infant joy faces |
↓ Activation |
2015 | Sacher et al. | PPD women <18 months postpartum Healthy postpartum women who cry due to sad mood <18 months postpartum Asymptomatic healthy postpartum women <18 months postpartum Healthy non-postpartum women |
Striatum PET | ↑ Increased MAO-A in PPD women and postpartum women who cry |
2016 | Moses-Kolko et al. | 17–20 year old mothers and non-mothers varying in levels of depressive symptoms 16 weeks postpartum | Striatum fMRI Monetary reward | ↑ Activity in non-mothers, but ≠ in mothers, with depressive symptoms |
2017 | Ho and Swain | Depressed mothers Non-depressed mothers | Functional connectivity fMRI Baby cry task | ↓ Functional connectivity between the NAc and the amygdala in depressed mothers, ↑ in healthy mothers |
2017 | Morgan et al. | 18–22 year old mothers varying in levels of depressive symptoms 17 weeks postpartum | Dorsal and ventral striatum fMRI Positive (i.e. happy) adult faces | ↓ Activation in mothers with higher depressive symptoms; for mothers with higher depressive symptoms, ↑ response associated with more positive caregiving, opposite pattern for mothers with lower symptoms |