Table 4.
First author | Patient groups | eHealth | Setting | Implementation project | Implementation framework | Implementation stage | Study design | Data collection |
Bailey [48] | COPDa | Clinical monitoring | Sheltered housing | 4 tenants used telehealth for 16 weeks | N/Ab | Middlec | Case study (QUALd) | Self-report assessment, observation, focus groups, interviews, workshops |
Boonstra [49] | Long-term illnesses | Video consultation | Homecare | From a database of 11,000 regular customers in 2006, 36 used the system | Structurationism | Middle | Single case study (MIXED) | Interviews, workshops, written reports, policy plans, meeting minutes, observations, quantitative data on system use |
Fortney [50] | Depression | ICBTe, Beating the Blues, video consultation | Primary care safety net clinics | Implement EBPf in 6 federally qualified health centers | RE-AIMg | Earlyh | Quality improvement methods (QUAL) | Qualitative needs assessments |
Hadjistavropoulos [51] | Anxiety, depression | ICBT, Wellbeing Course | Community mental health clinics | ICBT implementation in 7 community mental health clinics | CFIRi | Latej | Process evaluation (QUANTk) | Online survey |
Hendy [52] | Long-term illnesses | Clinical monitoring, WSDl | Primary care trusts | Case studies of 3 sites forming the WSD program | NPTm | Late | Comparative, longitudinal, qualitative, ethnographic case study (QUAL) | Interviews, meeting observations, document review |
Hendy [59] | Long-term illnesses | Clinical monitoring, WSD | Health and social care organizations | Case studies representing 5 large public sector health organizations | N/A | Late | Longitudinal, ethnographic case studies (QUAL) | Observations, document review, informal discussions, interviews |
Horton [53] | COPD | Clinical monitoring | Homecare | During the 6-month implementation period, only 10 users had been recruited to the scheme | N/A | Middle | Case study (QUAL) | Focus groups, field notes, meeting minutes |
Lindsay [54] | PTSDn, anxiety, depression, insomnia, chronic pain, SUDo | Video consultation, Video to Home | VAp Medical Center | This 2-year project included 93 patients | PARIHSq, RE-AIM | Late | Mixed-method program evaluation (MIXED) | Interviews, quantitative data on system use |
Taylor [55] | COPD, chronic HFr | Clinical monitoring | Community health care | 4 community nursing settings involved in 7-month program of action research | PDSAs | Middle | Case studies and action research methodologies (QUAL) | Workshop observations, focus groups, document review, field notes |
Terpstra [56] | Chronic pain | ICBT, Master Your Pain | Mental health care institutions | 13 mental health care institutions | TDFt, TAMu | Early | Descriptive design (QUANT) | Evaluation questionnaire |
Wells [57] | Chronic illness | Online PHRv | Health delivery organizations | Health care organizations that had had a PHR in place for at least 12 months | N/A | Late | Grounded theory inductive approach (MIXED) | Interviews, Web-based survey |
Wilhelmsen [58] | Depression | ICBT, Mood-GYM | General practice | 3-day training package for GPsw on ICBT | NPT | Late | Qualitative study (QUAL) | Telephone interviews |
aCOPD: chronic obstructive pulmonary disease.
bN/A: not applicable.
cMiddle: 4-12 months postimplementation startup.
dQUAL: qualitative.
eICBT: internet-delivered cognitive behavioral therapy.
fEBP: evidence-based practice.
gRE-AIM: reach, effectiveness, adoption, implementation, maintenance framework.
hEarly: 0-3 months postimplementation startup.
iCFIR: consolidated framework for implementation research.
jLate: >12 months postimplementation startup.
kQUANT: quantitative.
lWSD: Whole Systems Demonstrator.
mNPT: normalization process theory.
nPTSD: posttraumatic stress disorder.
oSUD: substance use disorder.
pVA: Veterans Affairs.
qPARIHS: promoting action on research implementation in health services.
rHF: heart failure.
sPDSA: plan, do, study, act.
tTDF: theoretical domains framework.
uTAM: technology acceptance model.
vPHR: patient health record.
wGP: general practitioner.