Table 1.
Study | N | Task | Speaking fo change | Steepest change |
Other measures |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
7Van Borsel | 2 | /ɑ/ and Reading | 200–220Hz to 130–160Hz | 4 mo | Jitter = Shimmer = PFR=* |
12 Damrose | 1 | /ɑ/ | 228 to 113 Hz | 3–4 mo | Shimmer ^ NHR ^ PFR=* |
13 Deuster | 11 | Reading | 79.4Hz (8.78ST) | 2–3 mo | |
5Nygren | 50 | Reading | 192 to 125Hz | PFR= | |
14Irwig & 16Hancock | 7 | /ɑ/, Reading | 135–183 to 87–128Hz (mean: −6.4 ST) | Jitter v Shimmer v NHR ~ PFR= |
|
17Zimman | 3 | Reading | 167–177Hz to 122–132Hz | First three formants (F1–3) ~ |
PFR: phonatory frequency range (maximum and minimum fo that the speaker can produce)
NHR: noise-to-harmonic ratio
Authors suggest that PFR reduced, but recalculating results in ST rather than Hz shows a stable PFR (<10% change)
Key
(average participant shows) no change;
increased;
decreased;
inconsistent between participants