Skip to main content
. 2010 Sep 20;36(ACS-8):1–26. doi: 10.14745/ccdr.v36i00a08

Table 2. Potential or Proven Benefits and Limitations of 1-Dose and 2-Dose Primary Varicella Vaccination in Children (see relevant section in text for references).

Potential outcomes One dose Two doses
Reduce varicella disease incidence, as compared to the pre-vaccine era Yes, by ~64% over an 80-year projection period * Yes, by ~86% over an 80-year projection period *
Reduce hospitalization Yes Anticipate further reduction
Reduce mortality Yes Anticipate further reduction
Reduce zoster incidence (all ages), as compared to pre-vaccine era Yes, by ~5% over an 80-year projection period * Yes, by ~11% over 80-year projection period *
Reduce zoster in the vaccinees Yes Anticipate further reduction
Reduce risk of secondary invasive Group A Streptococcus infection Yes (shown in the study by Patel et al.) Anticipate further reduction
Breakthrough disease (severity) Yes (in 7%–30%; the majority were mild cases) Yes, further reduction (in ~2%; all cases were mild)
Breakthrough cases can transmit infection Yes (especially if breakthrough disease is moderate–severe) Unknown (due to anticipated small number of cases)
Reduce outbreaks Yes, but outbreaks continue to occur in childcare centres and schools in the U.S. Anticipate further reduction (still too early to ascertain)
Antibody levels Lower seroconversion rates in post-licensure studies (after resetting the seroprotective titer to a higher level – see text) Significant boosting after the second dose whether administered 3 months later (2 doses of univalent vaccine) or 6 weeks to 4 years later (with 2 doses of MMRV)
Waning immunity Yes (based on outbreak studies) Anticipate less waning immunity (but rate of decline is unknown) *
Shift of varicella disease to older ages Shifted to mean of 22 years for wild type, and 41 years for breakthrough disease * Shifted to mean of 32 years for wild type, and 48 years for breakthrough disease *
Cost-effectiveness Cost-saving, for a single dose at 12 mos.* Cost-effectiveness ratios per QALY gained of 2-dose versus 1-dose vaccination: $106,000 (2 doses in the second year of life), $41,000 (2 doses at 12 mos. & preschool) and $28,000 (2 doses at 12 mos. & Grade 4), respectively *.

* Predicted in the model by Brisson et al., using base-case assumptions (71,72)