Table 4.
Study | Design | Condition | Patients (n) | Control Arm | IPL Device | Number Of IPL Sessions | Frequency | Outcomes | Concomitant Therapy |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Dell et al (2018) | Interventional Randomized Single-masked | MGD | 50 | Sham IPL + MGX | Lumenis | 4 | 2 | TBUT; OSDI; EDS; Eyelid appearance; meiboscore; incidence of adverse events; pain during procedure; biomicroscopy |
MGX |
Pyacomn et al (2018) | Interventional Randomized Double masked | MGD | 114 | Sham IPL | E>Eye | 3 | 1-2-6 | TBUT; OSDI; LLT; meiboscore; CFS; MGE; meibum quality; TFO (6 months follow-up) ST; IL-1Ra; IL-6 | Warm compression, lid scrub, non preservative ocular lubricants |
Wood et al (2017) | Interventional Randomized Double-masked | Evaporative DED | 14 | Sham IPL | / | 4 | / | TBUT (4 months follow up); OSDI (7 months follow up) | / |
Shen et al (2017) | Interventional randomized open label | Ocular rosacea | 20 | MGX | / | 4 | 4 | OSDI (4 months follow-up); pathologic microbial load (4 months follow-up); TGF-B1 (4 months follow-up) | MGX, topical anesthetic for DED |
Zadock et al (2017) | Interventional randomized single-masked | MGD | 24 | Sham IPL + MGX | Lumenis | 4 | 2 | TBUT (10 weeks follow-up); MG secretion score; OSDI; MGYLS; TFO; meiboscore; eyelid appearance (10 weeks follow-up) | MGX |
Dell et al (2015) | Interventional noncomparative | MGD | 44 | / | Lumenis | 4 | / | TBUT (3 weeks after each IPL session); CFS; MGS; SPEED; TFO; LLT; incidence of adverse events; immediate/short term skin response; subjective level of pain/discomfort | MGX |
Abbreviations: TBUT, tear break-up time; OSDI, ocular surface disease index; EDS, eye dryness score; LLT, lipid layer thickness; CFS, corneal fluorescein staining; MGE, meibomian gland expressibility; TFO, tear film osmolarity; MGLYS, meibomian glands yielding liquid secretion; SPEED, standard patient evaluation of eye dryness.