Table 5.
Study | Drug | Treated condition | Intervention vs. comparator | Ultrasound parameters | Outcome measures | Conclusion |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Elshazly et al. 10 | Dexamethasone sodium phosphate | Knee osteoarthritis | Phonophoresis vs. ultrasound | Phonophoresis: continuous mode; duration, 5 min; frequency, 1 MHz; intensity, 1 W/cm² Ultrasound: continuous mode; duration, 5 min; frequency, 1 MHz; intensity 0.8, W/cm² |
VAS Gait parameters |
Both effective. Phonophoresis significantly better |
Akinbo et al. 11 | Dexamethasone sodium phosphate | Knee osteoarthritis | Phonophoresis vs. iontophoresis | Phonophoresis: duration, 5 minutes; frequency, 1 MHz | WOMAC, 20 m ambulatory time, and knee ROM | Both effective. No significant difference |
Bakhtiary et al. 9 | Dexamethasone sodium phosphate | Carpal tunnel syndrome | Phonophoresis vs. iontophoresis | Phonophoresis: pulse mode, 1:4; duration, 5 minutes; frequency, 1 MHz; intensity, 1 W/cm² | VAS, pinch and grip strength and electro-neurographic measurement. | Phonophoresis more effective |
Saliba et al. 34 | Dexamethasone | Drug absorption | Phonophoresis vs. occlusive dressing and sham phonophoresis | Phonophoresis: pulse mode, 1:1; duration, 5 minutes; frequency, 3 MHz; intensity, 1W/cm² | Dexamethasone concentration in serum | Phonophoresis: higher dexamethasone serum levels. Negligible with sham phonophoresis |
Sedghimehr and Bahrpeima 36 | Hydrocortisone and clobetasol | Knee osteoarthritis | Phonophoresis vs. ultrasound, sham ultrasound and sham phonophoresis | None available (paper in Persian; abstract only in English) | VAS, Knee ROM, oedema, 20 m walking test | Phonophoresis more effective. Clobetasol had a faster effect |
Klaiman et al. 24 | Fluocinonide | Soft tissue disorders (epicondylitis, tendinitis, and tenosynovitis) | Phonophoresis vs. ultrasound | Phonophoresis: continuous mode; duration, 8 min; intensity, 1.5 W/cm² | VAS and pressure algometry | Both modalities effective. No significant difference |
Saraf and Singh 32 | Betamethasone | Chronic haemophilic knee synovitis | Phonophoresis | Phonophoresis: pulse mode, 1:1; duration, 5-6 min; frequency, 1 MHz | Degree of swelling, ROM, and frequencies of joint bleeding and joint tenderness | Phonophoresis effective |
Gurney et al. 35 | Hydrocortisone acetate | Drug absorption | Phonophoresis vs. sham phonophoresis | Phonophoresis: continuous mode; duration, 6 min; frequency, 1 MHz; intensity, 1 W/cm² | Cortisone level in connective tissue | No significant difference |
Penderghest et al. 33 | Dexamethasone- lidocaine | Tendinitis | Phonophoresis vs. sham phonophoresis | Pulsed mode | Pain (visual perceived pain scale, VPPS) and punctate tenderness gauge (PTG) | No significant difference. Effectiveness attributed to stretching, strengthening, and cryotherapy. |