Skip to main content
. 2019 Oct 22;14(10):e0223943. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0223943

Table 3. Virulence bioassay: Accumulated mortalities and Tukey test.

Treatment IO-20 IO-23 IO-27 IO-28 Control
Supernatant (24h) 60 ± 20 Aa 100 ± 0 Aa 73.33 ± 23.09 Aab 80 ± 20 Aa 20 ± 0 B df = 4; F = 10,000; P = 0.002.
Bacterial cells (24h) 80 ± 20 Aa 33.33 ± 23.09 Bb 100 ± 0 Aa 100 ± 0 Aa 20 ± 0 B df = 4; F = 22,857; P = 0.0001.
Supernatant (48h) 100 ± 0 Aa 93.33 ± 11.55 Aa 73.33 ± 11.55 Aab 73.33 ± 23.09 Aa 20 ± 0 B df = 4; F = 18,500; P = 0.0001.
Bacterial cells (48h) 86.66 ± 23.09 Aa 93.33 ± 11.55 Aa 53.33 ± 11.55 ABb 53.33 ± 23.09 ABa 20 ± 0 B df = 4; F = 9,850; P = 0.002.
df = 3; F = 1.212; P = 0.374. df = 3; F = 9.848; P = 0.005. df = 3; F = 4.934; P = 0.032. df = 3; F = 3.094; P = 0.090. *

Mortality rates (in %) determined for Providencia isolates assayed against adults of the olive fly. Values followed by the same letter are not statistically different using mean comparisons (Tukey test; P<0.05) angular transformed data. Capital letters represent comparisons within a row and lower case letters comparisons within a column. The asterisk “*” indicates that statistical analysis is not feasible (due to equal percentages for all data).