Skip to main content
. 2019 Sep 30;19(19):4261. doi: 10.3390/s19194261

Table 1.

Selected works dealing about the characterization, classification and authentication of food products with voltammetric electronic tongues.

Food Product Working Electrodes Data Analysis Comments Ref.
Orange juice and milk Pt and Au PCA First voltammetric e-tongue [14]
Milk Au, Pt, Rh, stainless steel PCA Monitoring of milk in dairy industry [28]
Au, Cu, Au modified with Prussian blue PCA Recognition of milk adulteration with hydrogen peroxide [29]
Au, Cu, Pt PCA Recognition of milk adulteration with urea, formaldehyde and melamine [30]
Au, Pd, Pt MPCA, NPLS-DA Recognition of milk adulteration with urea [31]
Au, Pt, Ag PCA, PLS-DA Discrimination of various brands of pure milk [32]
Au, Ag, Pt, Pd PCA, CA Monitoring of quality and storage time of unsealed pasteurized milk [15]
Yogurt Au, Ag, Pt, Pd SVM Monitoring the fermentation, post-ripeness and storage processes of set yogurts [33]
Au, Ag, Pt, Pd PCA, CA Evaluation of varieties of set yogurts [34]
Wines and liqueurs Phthalocyanine-based carbon paste electrodes and electrodes covered with conducting polypyrrole doped with different counter ions PCA Detection of adulterations in wines [16]
Au, Cu PCA Discrimination of wines and whiskies of different quality [35]
Au, Ag, Pt, Pd, W, Ti PCA, CA Classification of rice wines of different ages [36]
Five bulk-modified graphite-epoxy electrodes PCA, ANN Cava wine authentication [37]
Six bulk-modified graphite-epoxy electrodes LDA Cava wine authentication [17]
Five different graphite-epoxy composite electrodes PCA, ANN Discrimination of wines of different types and PDO [38]
Sensors based on metallic and bulk-modified graphite electrodes LDA Classification of wines of different PDO [39]
Four carbon paste electrodes chemically modified in different ways PCA Discrimination between red wines aged in oak barrels and matured in steel tanks in contact with oak wood chips [40]
Three nanocomposites modified electrodes prepared with Au and Cu nanoparticles in the presence of conducting polymers and carbon nanotubes. PCA, LDA Classification of rice wines of different geographical origins [41]
Six modified epoxy-composite electrodes LDA Classification of brandies according to their taste category and ageing method [42]
Four carbon paste electrodes: one unmodified and the others chemically modified with Co, Fe and Zn phthalocyanines PCA Discrimination of apple liqueurs [43]
Grapes Eight metallic electrodes housed inside a stainless steel cylinder PCA Study of grape ripening [44]
Poly-ethylendioxythiophene modified Pt electrode and sonogel carbon electrode PCA Study of grape ripening [45]
Beer Three enzymatic biosensors based on tyrosinase and phthalocyanines as mediators PCA, LDA Monitoring of the aging of beers [46]
Six bulk-modified graphite-epoxy electrodes PCA, LDA, PLS-DA Classification of three types of beer: Lager, Stout and IPA [47]
Four commercial screen-printed electrodes made of carbon, Au, carbon/Co-Phtahlocyanine and Pt PCA, LDA Classification of different types of beer [48]
Coffee Six graphite-epoxy electrodes modified in different ways LDA, SVM Geographical classification of Mexican coffees [49]
Au wire and graphite rod PCA Discrimination of civet coffee [50]
Tea Ir, Pt, Rh PCA Discrimination of nine different teas [51]
Au, Ir, Pd, Pt, Rh PCA, LDA Tea quality assessment [52,53]
Pt and glassy C PCA, LDA Classification of black tea liquor [54]
Metallic oxide-modified nickel foam electrodes (SnO2, ZnO, TiO2, Bi2O3) PCA, SVM Classification of green and black teas [55]
Au, Ir, Pd, Pt, Rh PCA Monitoring the fermentation process of black tea [56,57]
Honey Au, Ag, Pt, Pd, W, Ti PCA, CA, DFA Classification of mono-floral honeys [58]
Au, Ag, Pt, Pd, W, Ti PCA, DFA Tracing floral and geographical origins of honey [59]
Pt, Au, glassy C, Ag, Pd, Ni, Cu PCA, SVM, HCA Classification of Moroccan and French honeys according to geographical and botanical origins and detection of adulteration [60,61]
Au, Ag, Pt PCA, LDA Authentication of mono-floral and honeydew Romanian honeys [62]
Ir, Rh, Pt, Au PCA Monitoring honey adulteration with sugar syrups [63]
Au, Ag, Pt, glass electrode PLS-DA Monitoring honey adulteration [64]
Oil Six electrodes based on polypyrrole PCA, PLS-DA Discrimination of extra virgin olive oils according to their degree of bitterness [65]
Pt, Au, glassy C, Ag, Ni, Pd, Cu PCA, DFA, SVM Detection of adulteration in argan oil [66]
Modified carbon paste electrodes PLS-DA Detection of virgin olive oil adulteration [67]
Cu, glassy C, Au, Ni, Pd, Pt, Ag PCA, SVM, HCA Identification of Portuguese olive oils [68]
Meat and fish Screen-printed electrodes modified with bisphthalocyanine and polypyrrole PCA, PLS-DA Beef freshness monitoring by detection of ammonia and putrescine [69]
Pt, Au, Ag, glassy C, Pd, Cu, Ni PCA Assessment the origins of red meats and their storage time [70]
Ir, Rh, Pt, Au, Ag, Co, Cu, Ni PCA Shelf-life assessment of fresh cod in cold storage [71]