Abstract
Context:
The widely used Juniper Mini Asthma Quality of Life (MiniAQLQ) was devised and validated for self-completion under supervision. To calculate a score it is essential that all questions are completed correctly.
The problem:
When we administered the MiniAQLQ by post in a recent study, only 158/181 (87%) of responses were usable: 31 questions were omitted; 4 had double entries. The commonest error, in 12/181 (7%), was failure to complete Q15 (work-related problems)
Strategy for change:
We devised a patient instruction sheet on questionnaire completion and re-formatted the questionnaire to reduce the possibility of errors. Participants were sent the postal version a week before completing the questionnaires under supervision. The chi-square test was used to compare the rates of successful completion.
Effects of change:
96 participants were recruited. 93 postal questionnaires were returned: 83 (89%) were correctly completed. This was not significantly different to our previous study [Postal version vs Previous study: 83/93 vs 158/181: 2 = 0.22, p=0.679] 15 questions were omitted; there were no double entries. 8/93 (9%) did not complete Q15.
86 participants attended and completed the MiniAQLQ under supervision. There were no completion errors. [Supervised version vs postal version: 86/86 vs 83/93: 2 = 9.79, p=0.002] Including supervised attendance rate and postal return rate the overall usable response rates were similar. [Supervised vs Postal: 86/96 vs 83/96 2 = 0.44, p=0.505]
Conclusion:
Our instruction sheet did not reduce completion errors. However, the good return rate for postal administration achieved comparable overall usable response rates to the gold standard of supervised administration.
Full Text
The Full Text of this article is available as a PDF (147.6 KB).