Table 3.
References | Imaging | Anatomical place of the OSCC (n∘) | Diagnostic criteria of image invasion | Criteria for histological invasiveness |
---|---|---|---|---|
Handschel et al. [15] | CT | Mandible (58) | Three-point scale evaluation of cortical bone erosion. Invasion: periosteal impairment and bone | Three-point classification in relation to the degree of penetration into the cortical bone |
Oral floor(43) | ||||
Tongue(6) | ||||
Gu et al. [14] | CT | Tonsils (23) | Interruption or erosion of the peripheral edge with hyper-attenuation of the signal. Four-point scale of bone evaluation. Invasion probably or surely present Substitution of the peripheral signal hyposensitivity with tumor signal intensity in T1 and T2, or substitution of the hyperintense signal with intermediate tumor signal Dark areas corresponding to regions with high absorption of FDG adjacent to cortical bone showing a visible defect in the accumulation of FDG in the cortical or medullary sites of the same region Combined score scale: score of 4 for multiple tests, or a combined score >2. Like above Like above |
No distinction was made between the invasion of the cortical or bone marrow. Both were considered positive for invasion. |
MRI | Retromolar trine (8) | |||
PET/CT | Base of the tongue (6) | |||
CT+MRI | Oral floor(5) | |||
CT+PET/CT | Oral area (3) | |||
MR+PET/CT | Gingiva (1) | |||
CT+MRI+PET/CT | ||||
Hendrikx et al. [8] | CBCT | Retromolar trine(8) | Four-point scale in relation to bone compromise. Positive: slight invasion, obvious invasion Like above Like above |
Erosion: bone substituted but without invasion of the medullary spaces, of the mandibular canal and of the parodental ligament. Mandibular invasion: widespread tumor growth within the bone marrow, the root canal and if present in the periodontal ligament space |
Digital PR | Oral floor (9) | |||
MRI | Lower alveolar flange (3) | |||
Van Cann et al. [9] | CT | Retromolar trine (20) Oral floor (31) Lower alveolar flange (13) Mucous membrane (3) |
Absence of cortical bone adjacent to an abnormal soft tissue mass | Bone cortical invasion: bone replacement without invasion of the medullary spaces, the mandibular canal, or the periodontal ligament. Medullary invasion: diffuse growth of the tumor inside the bone marrow, of the root canal and if present in the periodontal ligament space |
MRI | Retromolar trine (20) Oral floor (31) Lower alveolar flange (13) Mucous membrane (3) |
Replacement of the peripheral signal hyperintensity with tumor signal intensity in T1 and T2, or substitution of the hyperintense signal with intermediate tumor signal. | ||
Digital PR | Retromolar trine (20) Oral floor (31) Lower alveolar flange (13) Mucous membrane (3) |
n.i | ||
SPECT | n.i. | |||
Van den Brekel et al. [13] | MRI | Retromolar process (9) | Tumor within the mandible or hyperintensity of the normal medullary signal replaced by an intermediate signal or an inflammatory eaction in T1 | Impairment of spongiosa and bone marrow |
CT | Oral floor (20) | Destruction of the external cortical bone and/or bone marrow. | ||
Digital PR | Three categories: absence of invasion. Minimum erosion. Extended invasion. Invasion: prevalence of bone destruction, replaced by the tumor | |||
Hakim et al. [12] | CT | Mandible(84) | Semi-quantitative scale with three evaluation points of cortical bone invasion. Bone erosion > at half the thickness of the cortical bone. Penetration of the cortical bone. Infiltration of bone marrow | Bone infiltration was established when tumor cells invaded and perforated the cortical bone (pT4a), according to the UICC/TNM classification for malignant tumors. |
CBCT | 3-D evaluation of the degree of bone involvement in the three axial, coronal, and sagittal planes, with semi-quantitative scale with three points of assessment of the bone invasion (see above) | |||
SPECT | ||||
Kolk et al. [16] | SPECT/CT | Mandible (50) | Classification of images in five categories. Evident involvement of the periosteum and bone. Probable involvement of the periosteum and bone. Not evident involvement of the periosteum and bone. Probably no periosteal involvement and certainly no mandibular erosion. No periosteal and bone involvement | Histological evaluation was conducted on horizontal sections throughout the tumor contact area using standard stains. The analysis of the vertical sections established the state of resection of the margins inside the bone marrow |
MRI | Like above | |||
MSCT | Like above |
n.i.: no information; UICC: union for international cancer control