Table 2. Summary of Model Fit and Variance Explained in External Variables for Dimensional, Categorical, and Hybrid Candidate Models of Interpersonal Problems Across Samples.
Sample | κ | Factors | Classes | Statistical model | AICC | BIC | Median R2 | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Range of ΔR2 | |||||||||||
General distress | Agency | Communion | Class membership | ||||||||
Note. Most favorable values are highlighted in bold print. κ = number of free parameters; AICC = corrected Akaike’s information criterion; BIC = Bayesian information criterion; Median R2 = average explained variance in external variables by sample; Range of ΔR2 = range of unique variance explained in external variables by sample; CFA-PC = confirmatory factor analysis (perfect circumplex); CFA-QC = confirmatory factor analysis (quasi circumplex); Skew-t-CFA = confirmatory factor analysis with non-normal latent skewed t-distribution; SP-FA = semiparametric factor analysis. LCA = Latent class analysis; VLMR = Vuong-Lo-Mendel-Rubin Test; BLRT = Bootstrapped Likelihood-Ratio Test. | |||||||||||
a Optimal number of classes by AICC. b Optimal number of classes by BIC. c Optimal number of classes by VLMR. d Optimal number of classes by BLRT. | |||||||||||
Sample 1 (N = 5,400) | 20 | 3 | CFA-PC | 111,545 | 111,413 | .32 | .10–.40 | .00–.08 | .00–.02 | ||
23 | 3 | CFA-QC | 111,496 | 111,344 | .32 | .10–.40 | .00–.08 | .00–.02 | |||
24 | 3 | Skew-t-CFA | 110,337 | 110,495 | .32 | .10–.40 | .00–.08 | .00–.02 | |||
36 | 3 | 5 | SP-FAa,b | 110,438 | 110,674 | .32 | .04–.14 | .00–.04 | .00–.01 | .00–.00 | |
52 | 5 | LCAc | 118,573 | 118,915 | .27 | .09–.40 | |||||
88 | 9 | LCAa,b,d | 114,771 | 115,348 | .28 | .09–.42 | |||||
Sample 2 (N = 491) | 20 | 3 | CFA-PC | 12,545 | 12,463 | .46 | .12–.49 | .00–.10 | .00–.11 | ||
23 | 3 | CFA-QC | 12,547 | 12,453 | .46 | .12–.49 | .00–.10 | .00–.11 | |||
21 | 3 | t-CFA | 12,418 | 12,505 | .46 | .12–.50 | .00–.10 | .00–.11 | |||
32 | 3 | 4 | SP-FAa,b | 12,305 | 12,435 | .45 | .02–.12 | .00–.02 | .00–.07 | .00–.01 | |
34 | 3 | LCAc | 12,910 | 13,047 | .33 | .03–.45 | |||||
79 | 8 | LCAa,b,d | 12,361 | 12,662 | .39 | .12–.51 | |||||
Sample 3 (N = 656) | 20 | 3 | CFA-PC | 13,622 | 13,710 | .13 | .01–.18 | .00–.09 | .00–.06 | ||
23 | 3 | CFA-QC | 13,719 | 13,617 | .13 | .01–.18 | .00–.09 | .00–.06 | |||
21 | 3 | t-CFA | 13,525 | 13,617 | .13 | .01–.18 | .00–.09 | .00–.06 | |||
24 | 3 | 2 | SP-FAa,b | 13,575 | 13,681 | .13 | .01–.13 | .00–.06 | .00–.06 | .00–.00 | |
34 | 3 | LCAc | 15,024 | 15,173 | .07 | .00–.12 | |||||
61 | 6 | LCAa,b,d | 14,446 | 14,707 | .07 | .00–.15 | |||||
Sample 4 (N = 712) | 20 | 3 | CFA-PC | 30,271 | 30,181 | .25 | .01–.23 | .00–.29 | .00–.15 | ||
23 | 3 | CFA-QC | 30,262 | 30,159 | .25 | .01–.23 | .01–.29 | .00–.15 | |||
21 | 3 | t-CFA | 29,831 | 29,926 | .25 | .01–.22 | .00–.29 | .00–.15 | |||
28 | 3 | 3 | SP-FAa,b | 29,908 | 30,034 | .25 | .00–.12 | .00–.17 | .00–.12 | .00–.02 | |
25 | 2 | LCAc | 31,968 | 32,080 | .08 | .00–.15 | |||||
43 | 4 | LCAa,b,d | 31,089 | 31,279 | .15 | .00–.23 |