SolidBin-naive |
None |
Taxonomy-independent |
None |
The NCut mode |
Comparable performance to other binners |
SolidBin-SFS |
ML |
Taxonomy-independent |
α
|
Take the contig pairs with high similarity as ML constraints |
Good performance when the number of samples is large. It can obtain good results with high similarity quality, and more samples could bring more useful coverage information |
SolidBin-coalign |
ML |
Taxonomy-dependent |
α
|
Take the contig pairs with the same assignment by TAXAassign as ML constraints |
Good performance when the genomes contained in the datasets are on the species level, while using the results from TAXAassign. It can obtain good results if the pairwise ML constraints have high accuracy |
SolidBin-CL |
CL |
Taxonomy-dependent |
β
|
Take the contig pairs assigned to different genera by TAXAassign as CL constraints |
Good performance when the genomes contained in the datasets are on the species level, often worse than SolidBin-coalign, while using the results from TAXAassign. It can obtain good results if the pairwise CL constraints have high accuracy |
SolidBin-SFS-CL |
ML |
Taxonomy-dependent |
α
|
Remove the contig pairs assigned to different genera by TAXAassign from the constraints set on the basis of SolidBin-SFS |
Often a little better than SolidBin-SFS at a cost of spending much time on taxonomy alignment |