Skip to main content
. 2019 Oct 16;11(10):1572. doi: 10.3390/cancers11101572

Table 1.

Potential sources of endometrial cancer (EC) diagnostic biomarkers, their advantages and disadvantages.

Potential Sources of EC Biomarkers Description Advantages Disadvantages
Blood
(serum/plasma)
Blood drawn into sample collection tubes. Easily accessible
Minimally invasive
High acceptability to both clinicians and patients.
Challenging matrix for proteomic analysis
High protein dynamic range
Low cancer derived proteins in early phases of disease.
Poor concordance with tissue-derived proteins
Hysterectomy specimens Tissue specimens obtained following hysterectomy Viable source of biomarkers
Relatively low protein dynamic range
Good matrix for proteomic analysis
Highly invasive
Low acceptability
Not feasible for pre-treatment diagnosis
Pipelle biopsy specimens Endometrial sampling by insertion of the pipelle into the uterine cavity either blindly or at hysteroscopy Viable source of biomarkers
Minimally invasive
Relatively low protein dynamic range
Relatively good matrix for proteomics
Useful in both symptomatic and asymptomatic women.
Severe pain in up to 25%
May miss focal pathologies
High risk of insertion failure (22% in nulliparous, 8% in parous)
Infection, bleeding, uterine perforation
Uterine lavage Saline is introduced into the uterine cavity and returned by aspiration. Viable source of biomarkers
Relatively low protein dynamic range
Relatively good matrix for proteomics
Useful in both symptomatic and asymptomatic women.
Relatively invasive
Discomfort and pain
Low acceptability especially in asymptomatic women
Pap Smear/cervical scrape A cervical brush is used to sample the ecto-cervix and the endocervical canal. Simple and minimally invasive
Low cost
Widely acceptable
Viable source of biomarkers
Discomfort from speculum examination
Intimate procedure
Less useful in asymptomatic women
Tao Brush biopsy specimens The Tao brush is inserted into the uterine cavity and used to obtain tissue specimens Less discomfort than pipelle biopsy
Viable source of biomarkers
Relatively low protein dynamic range
High cost
High risk of insertion failure (20% nulliparous, 8% in parous)
Vaginal tampons/swabs Vaginal tampons used for 8–12 h Minimally invasive
Potential source of uterine biomarkers in symptomatic women
Unappealing to postmenopausal women
Inadequate for EC detection in women without bleeding symptoms
Urine Usually self-collected Cheap, simple, non-invasive
High level of acceptability
Can be collected at home/in privacy
Relies on renal excretion of systemic biomarkers or urinary contamination by uterine biomarkers
Proteins and peptides are stable in urine and less complex
Biomarkers may not be excreted in urine
Urinary contamination by uterine biomarkers may be unreliable especially in asymptomatic or minimally symptomatic women
Wide variability in urinary protein concentrations