Table 1.
Potential Sources of EC Biomarkers | Description | Advantages | Disadvantages |
---|---|---|---|
Blood (serum/plasma) |
Blood drawn into sample collection tubes. | Easily accessible Minimally invasive High acceptability to both clinicians and patients. |
Challenging matrix for proteomic analysis High protein dynamic range Low cancer derived proteins in early phases of disease. Poor concordance with tissue-derived proteins |
Hysterectomy specimens | Tissue specimens obtained following hysterectomy | Viable source of biomarkers Relatively low protein dynamic range Good matrix for proteomic analysis |
Highly invasive Low acceptability Not feasible for pre-treatment diagnosis |
Pipelle biopsy specimens | Endometrial sampling by insertion of the pipelle into the uterine cavity either blindly or at hysteroscopy | Viable source of biomarkers Minimally invasive Relatively low protein dynamic range Relatively good matrix for proteomics Useful in both symptomatic and asymptomatic women. |
Severe pain in up to 25% May miss focal pathologies High risk of insertion failure (22% in nulliparous, 8% in parous) Infection, bleeding, uterine perforation |
Uterine lavage | Saline is introduced into the uterine cavity and returned by aspiration. | Viable source of biomarkers Relatively low protein dynamic range Relatively good matrix for proteomics Useful in both symptomatic and asymptomatic women. |
Relatively invasive Discomfort and pain Low acceptability especially in asymptomatic women |
Pap Smear/cervical scrape | A cervical brush is used to sample the ecto-cervix and the endocervical canal. | Simple and minimally invasive Low cost Widely acceptable Viable source of biomarkers |
Discomfort from speculum examination Intimate procedure Less useful in asymptomatic women |
Tao Brush biopsy specimens | The Tao brush is inserted into the uterine cavity and used to obtain tissue specimens | Less discomfort than pipelle biopsy Viable source of biomarkers Relatively low protein dynamic range |
High cost High risk of insertion failure (20% nulliparous, 8% in parous) |
Vaginal tampons/swabs | Vaginal tampons used for 8–12 h | Minimally invasive Potential source of uterine biomarkers in symptomatic women |
Unappealing to postmenopausal women Inadequate for EC detection in women without bleeding symptoms |
Urine | Usually self-collected | Cheap, simple, non-invasive High level of acceptability Can be collected at home/in privacy Relies on renal excretion of systemic biomarkers or urinary contamination by uterine biomarkers Proteins and peptides are stable in urine and less complex |
Biomarkers may not be excreted in urine Urinary contamination by uterine biomarkers may be unreliable especially in asymptomatic or minimally symptomatic women Wide variability in urinary protein concentrations |