Skip to main content
. 2019 Sep 27;9(10):258. doi: 10.3390/brainsci9100258

Table 1.

Overview of Neurophysiological Studies on Mindfulness using EEG Discussed in the Present Review. Note. State mindfulness = mindfulness induced by meditation; Trait mindfulness = dispositional mindfulness during resting state; ERD = event-related desynchronization; ERS = event-related synchronisation; ERP = event-related potential; OM = open monitoring; FA = focused attention; LPP = late positive potentials; MBCT = mindfulness-based cognitive therapy; MBT = mindfulness-based training; MBSR = mindfulness-based stress reduction. In studies where various meditation styles were examined, the results reported are those relevant to the meditation in bold font.

Study Sample (Meditators/Control) Form of Mindfulness/Meditation EEG Analyses Findings
Amihai and Kozhevnikov (2014) [72] 10 long-term Theravada meditators (average 8 years of practice)/9 long-term Vajrayana meditators (average 7.4 years of practice) Theraveda: Vipassana (OM), Kasina (FA); Vajrayana: Deity (OM), Rig-pa (FA) Spectral power; Coherence
  • ↑ gamma power during Vipassana vs. rest in left hemisphere.

Atchley et al. (2016) [73] 13 non-meditators/15 novice meditators/14 experienced meditators Mindfulness-based breath counting during tone task ERP
  • ↑ P3 amplitudes among meditators (novice and experienced) in comparison to non-meditators, in tone-only task (tones as target)

  • ↓ P3 amplitudes among meditators (novice and experienced) in comparison to non-meditators, when engaged in mindfulness-based breath counting during tone task (tones as distractor)

Berkovich-Ohana et al. (2012) [74] 36 mindfulness meditators/12 novice controls Mindfulness meditation (state mindfulness); Resting state (trait mindfulness) Spectral power
  • ↓ trait, frontal gamma power (mostly, right lateralized)

  • ↑ trait and state, temporal and parieto-occipital gamma power (mostly, right lateralized)

Berkovich-Ohana et al. (2013) [75] 36 mindfulness meditators/12 novice controls Mindfulness meditation (state mindfulness); Resting state (trait mindfulness) Mean Phase Coherence (MPC)
  • ↓ trait, right hemisphere theta MPC

  • ↓ trait, left hemisphere gamma MPC among long-term meditators

  • Negative correlation between trait, left gamma MPC, and meditation expertise

Braboszcz et al. (2017) [76] 20 Vipassana/20 Himalayan Yoga/27 Isha Shoonya/32 Control Vipassana, Himalayan Yoga, Isha Shoonya Spectral power
  • ↑ parieto-occipital gamma power

  • gamma power positively correlated with meditation experience

Brown et al. (2012) [77] 46 psychology undergraduates (within-subjects design) Dispositional mindfulness ERP
  • ↓ LPP amplitude among individuals higher in mindfulness, in response to high arousal, unpleasant pictures

Cahn et al. (2010) [78] 16 long-term meditators (within-subjects design) Vipassana meditation Spectral power
  • ↑ frontal theta power

  • ↑ parieto-occipital gamma power

  • occipital gamma power greatest among advanced/ long-term meditators (i.e., 10+ years)

Cahn et al. (2012) [79] 16 long-term meditators (within-subjects design) Vipassana (mindfulness) meditation Spectral power; Coherence
  • ↑ gamma power

  • ↑ gamma power in frontal, central, and parietal sites in long-term meditators

  • ↑ frontal gamma coherence (for longer-term meditators)

  • ↑ theta coherence

Delgado-Pastor et al. (2013) [80] 10 experienced meditators (within-subjects design) Vipassana (mindfulness) meditation ERP
  • ↑ P3b amplitudes to a target tone

Eddy et al. (2015) [81] 24 participants (within-subjects design) Induced mindfulness (through focused breathing) ERP
  • Induced mindfulness (i.e., decentering) correlated with ↓ P300 amplitudes for negative vs. neutral images

Egan et al. (2017) [82] 118 adult sample (within-subjects design) Brief mindfulness instructions ERP
  • ↑ LPP amplitude in brief mindfulness instructions

Hauswald et al. (2015) [83] 11 meditators (within-subjects design) Zen Spectral power
  • ↑ gamma power

  • ↓ frontal theta power

Lakey et al. (2011) [84] 9 naïve meditators/9 control Short, 6 minutes mindfulness induction ERP
  • ↑ P300 amplitude in central and temporal electrodes

Lehmann et al. (2012) [85] 13 Tibetan Buddhists/15 QiGong practitioners/14 Sahaja Yoga practitioners/14 Ananda Marga Yoga practitioners/15 Zen practitioners Various (including Zen) Spectral power; Lagged intracortical coherence; Head-surface conventional coherence
  • ↑ gamma power during meditation vs. resting as averaged across groups

  • ↑ theta head-surface conventional coherence in meditation vs. initial resting in Zen

  • ↓ lagged intracortical coherence during meditation vs. resting (for all meditation tradition) in all frequency bands

Lutz et al. (2004) [86] 8 long-term Buddhist practitioners/10 healthy student volunteers Loving kindness and compassion-focused meditation Spectral power; Coherence
  • ↑ gamma power in bilateral pareito-temporal and midfrontal electrodes

  • ↑ ratio of gamma power to low frequency power (4–13 Hz: Theta and Alpha) at medial frontoparietal electrodes at initial baseline; at frontolateral and posterior electrodes during meditation; and at anterior electrodes at post-meditative baseline

  • ↑ size of gamma coherence over lateral frontoparietal electrodes

  • Positive correlation between hours of meditation and gamma power at initial baseline

Miltz et al. (2014) [87] 23 naïve meditators (within-subjects design) Breath counting (indicative of a meditative state) Spectral power; Lagged intracortical coherence; Head-surface conventional coherence
  • ↓ theta intracortical lagged coherence between left middle frontal gyrus and right inferior parietal lobule

  • ↓ theta intracortical lagged coherence between left middle frontal gyrus and right cunues

  • ↑ gamma head-surface conventional coherence within the left anterior region

Slagter et al. (2007) [88] 17 participants/23 control (mixed design) 3-month meditation (Vipassana) retreat ERP
  • ↓ P3b amplitude to distractor stimuli

Sobolewski et al. (2011) [89] 13 meditators/13 control Mindfulness meditation ERP
  • ↓ LPP amplitude in frontal scalp regions to negatively valence visual stimuli

van Leeuwen et al. (2012) [90] 8 Buddhist monks and nuns/8 control
8 experienced FA meditators/6 controls (mixed design)
Zen (FA and OM meditation practices)
4-day OM meditation retreat
ERP
ERP
  • ↑ P300 amplitude in processing of small-sized targets (which is embedded within larger targets) in meditators only

  • In the processing of larger-sized targets, ↑ P300 amplitude in both meditators and control

  • Decreased attention processing towards detailed (small) targets from pre-retreat to post-retreat.

Wong et al. (2018) [91] 36 nurses (longitudinal design) 8-week MBT (based on MBSR) Spectral power; ERP
  • ↑ P300 amplitude