Skip to main content
. 2019 Oct 14;11(10):945. doi: 10.3390/v11100945

Table 2.

An overview of the different research studies pertaining to the involvement of pre-transplant BKPyV serology testing in post-transplantation BKPyV infection.

Authors Year Number of Patients Type of Assay and BKV Antigen Conclusions from the Study
Solis et al. [50] 2018 168 KTR + 69 donors Neutralization assay using pseudovirion system (BKPyV genotypes I, II, and IV) Recipients with high neutralizing antibody titer have a lower risk for developing BKPyV viremia
Abend et al. [23] 2016 116 donor-recipient pairs Neutralization inhibition assay using BKPyV particles (serotypes I, II, III, and IV)
VLP-based ELISA to detect antibodies against BKPyV serotype I
Donor with significant serum neutralizing activity is associated with elevated risk for BKPyV viremia regardless of recipient serostatus
Wunderink et al. [5] 2016 407 donor-recipient pairs Luminex assay detecting IgG reactivity against BKPyV Ib1 VP1 protein.
n = 396 reanalyzed by VP1 VLPs-based ELISA to detect antibodies against BKPyV genotype Ib2
Donor BKPyV IgG levels were strongly associated with the occurrence of recipient viremia and BKPyVAN
Sood et al. [54] 2013 192 adult and 11 pediatric donor-recipient pairs BKPyV VLPs-based ELISA to detect human IgG Antibodies Infection was highest in the Donor+/Recipient− group and lowest in the Donor−/Recipient− group
Ali et al. [52] 2011 36 pediatric KTRs + donors BKPyV VP1 VLPs-based indirect ELISA to detect human IgG antibodies Low BKPyV serostatus in children is associated with a high risk of post-transplantation BKPyV viremia, particularly in the context of donor with high BKPyV serostatus
Bijol et al. [55] 2010 45 pediatric KTRs BKPyV VLPs-based ELISA to detect human IgG antibodies Positive recipient BKPyV serostatus did not confer protection to BKV after transplantation
Bohl et al. [56] 2008 87 KTRs BKPyV VP1 VLPs-based ELISA to detect human IgG Antibodies Pre-transplant seropositivity did not protect against sustained BKPyV viremia but it might mitigate the severity of infection
Bohl et al. [51] 2005 142 recipients and 84 donors BKPyV VP1 VLPs-based ELISA to detect human IgG Antibodies BKPyV infection in the recipient was strongly associated with a positive BKPyV donor antibody status
Smith et al. [57] 2004 173 pediatric KTRs BKPyV VP1 VLPs-based indirect ELISA to detect human IgG Antibodies Recipient seronegativity for BKPyV was significantly associated with the development of BKPyVAN
Hirsch et al. [15] 2002 77 KTRs Hemagglutination inhibition assay The high-risk group is not the seropositive donor and seronegative recipient transplant combination
Flegstad et al. [58] 1991 10 KTRs Neutralization inhibition assay
Hemagglutination inhibition assay
IgG, IgA, and IgM ELISA
Positive recipient BKPyV serostatus did not confer protection to BKPyV after transplantation
Children with BK nephritis demonstrated lower pretransplant antibodies levels when compared to control groups (no infection)
Andrews et al. [53] 1988 496 donor-recipient pairs Hemagglutination inhibition assay A seropositive donor increased the rate of primary and reactivation infections with BKPyV