Table 2.
Authors | Year | Number of Patients | Type of Assay and BKV Antigen | Conclusions from the Study |
---|---|---|---|---|
Solis et al. [50] | 2018 | 168 KTR + 69 donors | Neutralization assay using pseudovirion system (BKPyV genotypes I, II, and IV) | Recipients with high neutralizing antibody titer have a lower risk for developing BKPyV viremia |
Abend et al. [23] | 2016 | 116 donor-recipient pairs | Neutralization inhibition assay using BKPyV particles (serotypes I, II, III, and IV) VLP-based ELISA to detect antibodies against BKPyV serotype I |
Donor with significant serum neutralizing activity is associated with elevated risk for BKPyV viremia regardless of recipient serostatus |
Wunderink et al. [5] | 2016 | 407 donor-recipient pairs | Luminex assay detecting IgG reactivity against BKPyV Ib1 VP1 protein. n = 396 reanalyzed by VP1 VLPs-based ELISA to detect antibodies against BKPyV genotype Ib2 |
Donor BKPyV IgG levels were strongly associated with the occurrence of recipient viremia and BKPyVAN |
Sood et al. [54] | 2013 | 192 adult and 11 pediatric donor-recipient pairs | BKPyV VLPs-based ELISA to detect human IgG Antibodies | Infection was highest in the Donor+/Recipient− group and lowest in the Donor−/Recipient− group |
Ali et al. [52] | 2011 | 36 pediatric KTRs + donors | BKPyV VP1 VLPs-based indirect ELISA to detect human IgG antibodies | Low BKPyV serostatus in children is associated with a high risk of post-transplantation BKPyV viremia, particularly in the context of donor with high BKPyV serostatus |
Bijol et al. [55] | 2010 | 45 pediatric KTRs | BKPyV VLPs-based ELISA to detect human IgG antibodies | Positive recipient BKPyV serostatus did not confer protection to BKV after transplantation |
Bohl et al. [56] | 2008 | 87 KTRs | BKPyV VP1 VLPs-based ELISA to detect human IgG Antibodies | Pre-transplant seropositivity did not protect against sustained BKPyV viremia but it might mitigate the severity of infection |
Bohl et al. [51] | 2005 | 142 recipients and 84 donors | BKPyV VP1 VLPs-based ELISA to detect human IgG Antibodies | BKPyV infection in the recipient was strongly associated with a positive BKPyV donor antibody status |
Smith et al. [57] | 2004 | 173 pediatric KTRs | BKPyV VP1 VLPs-based indirect ELISA to detect human IgG Antibodies | Recipient seronegativity for BKPyV was significantly associated with the development of BKPyVAN |
Hirsch et al. [15] | 2002 | 77 KTRs | Hemagglutination inhibition assay | The high-risk group is not the seropositive donor and seronegative recipient transplant combination |
Flegstad et al. [58] | 1991 | 10 KTRs | Neutralization inhibition assay Hemagglutination inhibition assay IgG, IgA, and IgM ELISA |
Positive recipient BKPyV serostatus did not confer protection to BKPyV after transplantation Children with BK nephritis demonstrated lower pretransplant antibodies levels when compared to control groups (no infection) |
Andrews et al. [53] | 1988 | 496 donor-recipient pairs | Hemagglutination inhibition assay | A seropositive donor increased the rate of primary and reactivation infections with BKPyV |