Table 2.
Authors Year/Country |
Study design/Purpose | Subjects | Parent-Infant contact method/Theoretical construct | Outcome Measures/Time Points | Primary Results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Feldman, Weller, Zagoory-Sharon, & Levine, 2007 Israel |
Prospective longitudinal design Compared OT levels in mothers during pregnancy and postpartum months, and examine whether OT levels are indicative of what maternal behaviors are expressed during postpartum. |
Pregnant women: n = 62 | 15 min of mother-infant interaction. Theoretical construct of study not described. |
Plasma M-OT; Maternal screening of anxiety and depression done through questionnaires before giving birth; Coded behaviors included: Maternal gaze, affect, touch, and vocalization. Follow-up: 1st trimester, 3rd trimester, & infant at 1 month of age |
Individual OT levels showed stability over time. Certain maternal behaviors were found to be related to OT, the strongest correlation being a mother constantly checking on their infant, P < 0.01. |
Gordon, Zagoory-Sharon, Leckman, & Feldman, 2010 Israel |
Prospective longitudinal design Compared plasma M-OT & P-OT across first 6 months after birth and interrelatedness OT with cohabitating partners; examined M-OT & P-OT related to maternal/paternal behavioral characteristics. |
Parents: n = 128 (66 mothers, 62 fathers) First born infants: n = 80 (37 males, 43 females) |
Video of 10-min parents infant free-play interaction Theoretical construct of study not described. |
Plasma M-OT and P-OT; Composite scores of parents-infant behaviors for gaze, affect, proximity position, and touch created categories. Follow-up: 1st postpartum weeks & 6 months |
Provided normative data for OT in mothers & fathers. Peripheral OT in cohabitating parents are interrelated. Mothers & fathers show similar levels of OT across time, first 6 months P< 0.01. Mothers ↑ affectionate parenting touch behaviors P < 0.05. Fathers had more stimulatory parenting touch behaviors P < 0.05. |
Gordon, Zagoory-Sharon, Leckman, & Feldman, 2010 Israel |
Prospective longitudinal design Examined the relationship between M-OT and P-OT with patterns of touch and contact in the family unit during triadic interactions. |
Parents: n = 74 (37 couples) First-born infants: n = 37 (22 female, 15 male) |
Video of 10-min parent-infant free play triadic interaction Theoretical Construct: Family system's approach; focused on M-OT & P-OT in shaping parents' engagement in synchronous & coherent triadic interactions. |
Plasma M-OT & P-OT; salivary cortisol; Composite score of behavioral triadic synchrony. Follow-up: 2 months & 6 months age |
Plasma M-OT, P-OT and salivary cortisol levels are stable over time P < 0.001. Parents' triadic synchrony scores were correlated P < 0.001. Mothers with ↑OT & ↓ SC predict triadic synchrony. For fathers, only OT independently predicted triadic synchrony. |
Feldman, Gordon, Influs, Gutbir, & Ebstein, 2013 Israel |
Prospective longitudinal design Examined the possible cross-generational transfer of human attachment through hormonal systems, genetics, and observed interactions. |
Parents: n = 160 (80 couples) Firstborn infants n = 80 Baseline: 1 month age; 6 months: (66 mothers, 62 fathers) 3 years: (50 mothers, 48 fathers, 50 friends of infant) |
1 month: videotaped parent and infant freely interacting. 6 months: videotaped parent and infant freely interacting. 3 years: each parent-infant interaction for 7-min. Then, a 10-min interaction between child and best friend was videotaped during structured play. Theoretical construct of study not described. |
Plasma & salivary M-OT & P-OT; Genotyping; At 1 month visit categories of parenting behavior. Early Parental Care composite score given. A cumulative OT risk’ score was computed. At 3 yrs Coding Interactive Behavior composite score for social interactions. Follow-up: 1 month, 6 month, & 3 years of age |
Demonstrated individual stability in parental peripheral OT P < 0.001 and behavior with genetic variability over several years. Child OT correlated with M-OT P < 0.01. Early maternal care was associated with mother-child reciprocity at 3 years P < 0.05. Bio-behavioral experiences within parent-infant bond shapes child's affiliative biology and social behavior across multiple attachments. Children's social reciprocity with best friend was associated with mother- child reciprocity P < 0.01. |
Gordon, Pratt, Bergunde, Zagoory-Sharon, & Feldman, 2017 Israel/USA |
Prospective longitudinal design Examined the interaction of OT and testosterone implicated in parental care, and its effect on synchrony and gender-specific behaviors |
Parents: n = 160 (80 couples) Firstborn Infants: n = 80 (37 female, 43 male) |
5 min of play between infant and both parents. Theoretical Construct: Bio-behavioral Synchrony Model such that ↑ parental OT stimulates human specific parental repertoire of synchronous parent-infant interactions. |
Plasma OT & testosterone; Parental behaviors coded for vocalizations, affect, touch, synchrony, and gaze. Follow-up: 1 month & 6 month of age |
Parental OT levels were stable overtime. M-OT coupled with a ↑ testosterone was associated with ↑ affectionate touch, P < 0.01. An ↑ testosterone in fathers was negatively correlated with lower OT and affectionate touch, P < 0.05. |
Note: OT= Oxytocin, SC = salivary cortisol, M-OT = maternal oxytocin, P-OT = paternal oxytocin.