Skip to main content
. 2019 Nov 5;7:e7981. doi: 10.7717/peerj.7981

Table 2. Ranking of the stability values of the 10 candidate reference genes based on five algorithms in the methoprene bioassay in the head of C. formosanus.

RefFinder ΔCt NormFinder geNorm BestKeeper
Gene GM Genes SV Gene SV Gene SV Gene SD Gene [r] P-value
RPS18 1.19 RPS18 0.66 RPS18 0.19 RPS18 0.34 GAPDH 0.56 HSP70 0.94 0.001
EF1-α 2.59 HSP70 0.71 HSP70 0.33 EF1-α 0.34 RPS18 0.57 RPS18 0.94 0.001
HSP70 3.25 EF1-α 0.71 EF1-α 0.36 RPL32 0.415 NADH 0.66 EF1-α 0.89 0.001
RPL32 4.12 RPL32 0.73 RPL32 0.40 HSP70 0.423 RPL13a 0.76 RPL32 0.89 0.001
GAPDH 4.30 RPL13a 0.74 RPL13a 0.42 RPL13a 0.48 EF1-α 0.77 Ctyb 0.86 0.001
RPL13a 4.73 NADH 0.74 NADH 0.43 NADH 0.52 RPL32 0.81 RPL13a 0.85 0.001
NADH 5.05 GAPDH 0.77 GAPDH 0.48 GAPDH 0.54 HSP70 0.87 NADH 0.82 0.001
Ctyb 8.00 Ctyb 0.89 Ctyb 0.66 Ctyb 0.59 Ctyb 0.98 GAPDH 0.78 0.001
β-actin 9.00 β-actin 1.19 β-actin 1.04 β-actin 0.71 β-actin 1.02 β-actin 0.66 0.001
18S 10.00 18S 1.47 18S 1.38 18S 0.86 18S 1.14 18S 0.60 0.001

Notes:

GM, geometric mean; SV, stability value; SD, standard deviation; [r], Pearson’s correlation coefficient.