Skip to main content
. 2018 Oct 25;64(2):431–442. doi: 10.1111/1556-4029.13938

Table 4.

Descriptive statistics for Experiments 2 and 3

Segmentation method Metrics of Performance
(A) Absolute Error (residuals) in the Extent of the Foreground (%) (B) Relative Error (mis‐estimation) in the Extent of the Foreground (%) (C) Dice Coefficient Values
N Mean SD N Mean SD N Mean SD
Manual
Manual segmentation (tracing) 30 0.11 1.62 30 2.35 26.65 30 0.82 0.08
Manually defined threshold (1 examiner) 200 −0.96 3.73 200 −21.06 41.73 200 0.82 0.13
Manually defined threshold (20 examiners) 200 0.95 6.45 200 11.50 96.68 200 0.72 0.23
Global algorithms
Default 10 3.84 7.74 10 70.48 144.25 10 0.62 0.30
Huang 10 25.44 21.11 10 567.20 594.79 10 0.33 0.32
Intermodes 10 −3.22 2.77 10 −51.82 36.62 10 0.74 0.22
IsoData 10 2.98 6.20 10 55.49 116.19 10 0.63 0.29
Li 10 9.61 11.37 10 159.87 211.10 10 0.54 0.34
MaxEntropy 10 −0.77 4.72 10 −22.40 51.96 10 0.79 0.16
Mean 10 24.26 9.41 10 466.74 329.82 10 0.32 0.30
MinError 10 53.74 20.58 10 917.85 565.52 10 0.20 0.20
Minimum 10 −5.09 2.69 10 −73.91 31.45 10 0.33 0.31
Moments 10 1.92 3.13 10 28.79 42.01 10 0.66 0.28
Otsu 10 1.44 3.17 10 25.42 51.20 10 0.64 0.28
Percentile 10 41.94 6.15 10 763.39 491.28 10 0.23 0.23
RenyiEntropy 10 0.18 5.08 10 −12.75 54.85 10 0.78 0.16
Shanbhag 10 −3.01 3.76 10 −52.57 46.90 10 0.55 0.31
Triange 10 4.04 3.24 10 51.82 41.91 10 0.59 0.25
Yen 10 0.58 5.69 10 −9.99 59.01 10 0.78 0.17