Table 5.
Element | Year (for our study only) | CO2 effect (%) | Temp. effect (%) | Canopy layer effect (%) | Reported CO2 effecta (%) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
B | 2014 | ns | +19.8 |
+1.5 +1.6 |
−6.4 (< 0.0001) |
2015 | −6.0 | +17.0 |
ns ns |
||
Ca | 2014 | −5.5 | +9.1 |
+13.9 +13.5 |
−5.8 (< 0.0001) |
2105 | ns | +17.9 |
+5.0 +5.2 |
||
Cu | 2014 | ns | ns | ns | −5.7 (< 0.0001) |
2015 | ns | ns | ns | ||
Fe | 2014 | −8.7 | +11.1 |
−12.5 −2.1 |
−4.1 (< 0.0001) |
2015 | −7.7 | +7.4 |
−12.5 −6.3 |
||
K | 2014 | 3.1 | ns | ns | 0.1 (0.857) |
2015 | ns | ns |
−3.1 −0.4 |
||
Mg | 2014 | ns | ns |
−0.2 −5.1 |
−3.5 (< 0.0001) |
2015 | ns | +7.0 |
−1.3 −3.4 |
||
Mn | 2014 | ns | ns |
+8.8 +15.8 |
−1.4 (0.204) |
2015 | ns | +5.8 |
+10.9 +18.0 |
||
P | 2014 | ns | −10.9 |
+1.1 +2.6 |
−0.7 (0.379) |
2015 | ns | ns |
−1.4 +3.9 |
||
S | 2014 | ns | +3.6 | ns | −2.9 (< 0.0001) |
2015 | −9.6 | ns |
+9.4 +5.9 |
||
Se | 2014 | ns | ns |
−0.6 −24.5 |
|
2015 | ns | ns |
ns ns |
||
Zn | 2014 | ns | +3.4 |
+0.2 −5.8 |
−5.1 (< 0.0001) |
2015 | −8.9 | +6.4 |
−5.4 −2.4 |