Table 1.
In vivo T1D models | Critical findings | Advantages | Shortcomings | References |
---|---|---|---|---|
NOD mouse | CD4+ and CD8+ T cells, as well as B cells, are integral to disease development | Parallels the polygenic nature of T1D and importance of MHC | Differences in disease kinetics, inflammatory infiltrate composition, islet cell architecture, pancreas morphology, and number of PLN | 5, 6, 10, 11, 12, 14, 15, 16, 17, 22, 75, 120 |
Islet antigen specific T cells recognize Ins B:9–23, Ins1 B5–14 and Ins1/2 A2–10 | ||||
ChgA and IAPP are autoantigens and function to initiate disease and promote Th1 responses | Serves as a valuable pre‐clinical model for therapeutics | Differences in endocrine cell distribution, β‐cell regenerative capacity, and immune cell receptor expression and signaling | ||
Antigen specific T cells recognize post‐translationally modified epitopes which may alter binding to MHC molecules | Capacity for transgenics, adoptive transfers and lineage tracing, and intervention testing in a spontaneous model system | |||
NOD‐scid Il2rγ −/− (NSG) mouse | Adoptively transferred CD8+ T cells from T1D donors stimulated with pooled islet antigen peptides [IGRP, IAPP, Ins, and IA‐2] traffic to the islets and produce IFN‐γ | Lack endogenous T, B and NK cells | Increased β‐cell proliferative capacity as compared to humans | 6, 19 |
Can be engrafted with human PBMCs | Alterations in homing, chemokine and cytokine use, and secondary lymphatics in xenogeneic system | |||
NOD‐SCID BLT HLA‐DQ8 transgenic mouse | Demonstrated the in vivo pathogenicity of human HLA‐DQ8 restricted InsB:9–23 specific CD4+ T cells in exacerbating insulitis and β‐cell death | Possess a complete human lymphoid and myeloid immune cell repertoire | GVHD and wasting syndrome | 6, 20 |
T cells are educated autologously and are HLA restricted | ||||
HLA‐A2.1 transgenic NOD mouse | Accelerated disease compared to nontransgenic NOD mouse | Possession of human HLA molecules allow for testing a variety of agents, including adoptive cell therapy, and ASI on human cells in vivo | Often reduced disease incidence as compared to NOD | 7, 8, 9, 13 |
Islet infiltrating T cells directly lyse HLA‐A2.1+ β‐cells | ||||
NOD.β2mnull.HHD mouse | CD8+ islet infiltrating T cells from HLA‐A2.1 transgenic mice target an IGRP epitope cross‐reactive to human IGRP (IGRP228–236) | |||
NOD.mβ2mnull.hβ2m.HLA‐A11 transgenic mouse | HLA‐A11 restricted CD8+ islet infiltrating T cells in HLA‐A11 transgenic mice recognize IGRP and Ins C‐peptide and are present prior to disease onset | |||
Foxp3‐GFP‐Cre × R26‐YFPNOD transgenic mouse model | GFP–YFP+Foxp3– ex‐Treg which lost Foxp3 were identifiable and shown to have a pro‐inflammatory phenotype | Facilitates genetic lineage tracing | Potential for off‐target Cre recombination | 18 |
Can identify plasticity in cell lineages and sort out these plastic populations to conduct functional studies | ||||
Trafficking and localization can be visualized in situ |
ASI = Antigen specific immunotherapy; Ins = Insulin; ChgA = Chromogranin A; IAPP = Islet Amyloid Polypeptide; IGRP = Islet‐specific glucose‐6‐phosphatase catalytic subunit‐related protein; IA‐2 = Islet antigen‐2; BLT = Bone marrow, Liver, Thymus; NK = Natural Killer; PBMCs = Peripheral blood mononuclear cells; GVHD = Graft Versus Host Disease; Tregs = regulatory T cells.