Skip to main content
. 2019 Nov 1;21(11):e13478. doi: 10.2196/13478

Table 3.

Critical appraisal of included studies.

Study Q1a Q2b Q3c Q4d Q5e Q6f Q7g Q8h Q9i Q10j Q11k Q12l Q13m
Conaughton et al [22] Yes Yes Yes Unclear No Yes No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes
Esposito et al [23] Unclear Unclear Yes Unclear Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Fletcher-Watson et al [24] Yes Yes Yes No Unclear Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Fridenson-Hayo et al [25] Unclear Unclear Yes No No Unclear Yes Yes Unclear Yes Yes Yes Yes
Whitehouse et al [26] Unclear Unclear Yes No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Himle et al [27] Unclear Unclear Yes No No Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes
Ricketts et al [28] Yes Unclear Yes No No Unclear Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Bul et al [29] Yes No Yes No Unclear Unclear Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Coutinho et al [30] Yes Unclear Yes Unclear Unclear Unclear Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
De Castro et al [31] Unclear Unclear Yes Unclear Unclear Unclear Yes Yes Unclear Yes Yes Yes Yes
Number that met the criteria (%) 50 20 100 0 10 50 90 100 70 90 100 100 100

aQ1: True randomization.

bQ2: Allocation concealed.

cQ3: Treatment groups similar at the baseline.

dQ4: Participants blind to treatment.

eQ5: Those delivering intervention blind to treatment.

fQ6: Outcome assessors blind to treatment.

gQ7: Treatment groups treated identically.

hQ8: Follow-up complete and if not, differences between groups adequately described and analyzed.

iQ9: Participants analyzed in the groups to which they were randomized.

jQ10: Outcomes measured in the same way for groups.

kQ11: Outcomes measured reliably.

lQ12: Appropriate statistical analysis.

mQ13: Appropriateness of trial design and any deviations from RCT design accounted for.