Table 1. Baseline characteristics of enrolled studies.
| Study | Type | Time (published) | Country | Jadad scale (randomization + concealment of allocation + double blinding + withdrawals and dropouts) | Participant | Age (A vs. B) | Male/total (A vs. B) | Total number (A vs. B) | Mortality (A vs. B) | A; B |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Annane et al. | RCT | 2007 | France | 1+1+1+0=3 | Multi-center | – | – | 161; 169 | 64; 58 | Epinephrine; norepinephrine+ dobutamine |
| Baske et al. | RCT | 2018 | India | 2+2+2+1=7 | One center | – | 14/20; 13/20 | 20; 20 | 14; 16 | Epinephrine; dopamine |
| Choudhury et al. | RCT | 2017 | India | 2+2+0+1=5 | One center | 46.76±12.11; 48.29±12.53 | 35/42; 34/42 | 42; 42 | 32; 36 | Terlipressin; norepinephrine |
| De Backer et al. | RCT | 2010 | Spain | 2+2+0+1=5 | Multi-center | – | – | 542; 502 | 291; 249 | Dopamine; norepinephrine |
| Gordon et al. | RCT | 2016 | United Kingdom | 2+2+2+1=7 | Multi-center | – | 111/204; 127/204 | 204; 204 | 63; 56 | Vasopressin; norepinephrine |
| Gordon et al. | RCT | 2010 | Canada | 1+1+1+1=4 | Multi-center | – | – | 397; 382 | 140; 150 | Vasopressin; norepinephrine |
| Hammond et al. | RCT | 2018 | France | 1+1+0+0=2 | One center | 62 [51–74]; 60 [49–68] | 22/41; 18/41 | 41; 41 | 19; 18 | Vasopressin + norepinephrine; norepinephrine |
| Hua et al. | RCT | 2013 | China | 2+1+0+0=3 | One center | 52.2±14.0; 56.6±16.4 | 8/16; 10/16 | 16; 16 | 8; 7 | Dopamine; terlipressin |
| Jain et al. | RCT | 2010 | India | 2+1+2+0=5 | One center | 42.88±5.39; 45.29±7.41 | 15/27; 13/27 | 27; 27 | 15; 16 | Norepinephrine; phenylephrine |
| Levy et al. | RCT | 1997 | France | 1+1+0+0=2 | One center | 54±10; 56±9 | 10/15; 11/15 | 15; 15 | 9; 8 | Epinephrine; norepinephrine+ dobutamine |
| Lauzier et al. | RCT | 2006 | Canada | 2+2+0+0=4 | Two centers | 58.1±17.5; 51.2±17.2 | 8/10; 6/13 | 10; 13 | 3; 3 | Norepinephrine; vasopressin |
| Luckner et al. | RCT | 2006 | Austria | 1+1+0+0=2 | One center | – | – | 10; 8 | 8; 7 | Vasopressin + norepinephrine; norepinephrine |
| Marik et al. | RCT | 1994 | – | – | One center | – | – | 10; 10 | 5; 6 | Norepinephrine; dopamine |
| Mathur et al. | RCT | 2007 | – | – | One center | – | – | 25; 25 | 14; 19 | Norepinephrine; dopamine |
| Martin et al. | RCT | 1993 | – | – | One center | – | – | 16; 16 | 7; 10 | Norepinephrine; dopamine |
| Morelli et al. | RCT | 2008 | Italy | 2+1+0+1=4 | One center | 70 [53–74]; 70 [59–74] | 11/14; 13/19 | 16; 16 | 10; 9 | Phenylephrine; norepinephrine |
| Morelli et al. | RCT | 2008 | Italy | 1+1+0+1=3 | One center | 66 [28–84]; 67 [29–83] | 13/19; 14/20 | 19; 20 | 12; 14 | Terlipressin; norepinephrine |
| Morelli et al. | RCT | 2009 | Italy | 2+1+0+1=4 | One center | 67 [60–71]; 66 [60–74]; 64 [59–72] | 11/15; 10/15; 12/10 | 15; 15; 15 | 7; 8; 10 | Terlipressin; vasopressin; norepinephrine |
| Myburgh et al. | RCT | 2008 | Australia | 2+2+2+1=7 | Mult-center | 59.4±15.9; 60.4±14.8 | 10/64; 7/63 | 64; 63 | 15; 17 | Epinephrine; norepinephrine |
| Mahmoud et al. | RCT | 2012 | Egypt | 2+2+2+0=6 | One center | 52.4±4.5; 50.3±6.5 | 16/30; 15/30 | 30; 30 | 15; 16 | Norepinephrine + dobutamine; norepinephrin + epinephrine |
| Mehta et al. | RCT | 2013 | Canada | 1+1+1+1=4 | 9 centers | 62.9 [51.2–73.6]; 65.5 [50.8–76.1] | 43/65; 42/56 | 65; 56 | 27; 24 | Vasopressin; norepinephrine |
| Patel et al. | RCT | 2010 | USA | 1+1+0+0=2 | One center | – | 64/134; 52/118 | 134; 118 | 67; 51 | Dopamine; norepinephrine |
| Ruokonen et al. | RCT | 1993 | Finland | 1+1+0+0=2 | One center | 18-76; 39–53 | – | 5; 5 | 4; 3 | Norepinephrine; dopamine |
| Ramaswamy et al. | RCT | 2016 | India | 2+2+2+1=7 | One center | 7 [1–11]; 4 [0.8–8] | 15/29; 15/31 | 29; 31 | 14; 18 | Epinephrine; dopamine |
| Russell et al. | RCT | 2009 | Australia | 1+1+1+1=4 | Mult-center | – | – | 396; 382 | 140; 150 | Vasopressin; norepinephrine |
| Russell et al. | RCT | 2008 | Canada | 2+2+2+1=7 | Mult-center | 59.3±16.4; 61.8±16 | 246/396; 229/382 | 396; 382 | 140; 150 | Vasopressin; norepinephrine |
| Russell et al. | RCT | 2013 | Canada | 1+1+1+0=3 | Multi-center | 60.7±16.7; 60.0±15.7 | 121/191; 112/203 | 191; 203 | 65; 60 | Norepinephrine; vasopressin |
| Schmoelz et al. | RCT | 2006 | Germany | 2+1+2+0=2 | One center | 49.24±19.03; 56.7±18.5 | 14/22; 10/21 | 22; 21 | 4; 5 | Dopamine; dopexamine |
| Seguin et al. | RCT | 2002 | France | 1+1+0+0=2 | One center | 65±12; 70±13 | 6/10; 6/11 | 10; 11 | 4; 5 | Epinephrine; norepinephrine+ dobutamine |
| Seguin et al. | RCT | 2006 | France | 1+1+0+0=2 | One center | 67±13; 65±10 | – | 10; 12 | 3; 2 | Epinephrine; dopexamine + norepinephrine |
| Ventura et al. | RCT | 2015 | Brazil | 2+2+2+1=7 | One center | 39.6±46.3 months; 56.9±58.2 months | 35/63; 35/57 | 63; 57 | 13; 4 | Dopamine; epinephrine |
RCT, randomized controlled trial.