Skip to main content
. 2019 Nov 19;2019(11):CD012187. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012187.pub2
Study Treatment Total number of participants reporting ≥ 1adverse event Serious adverse events Total all‐cause withdrawals Withdrawals due to adverse events
Arambasik 2013 Treatment group (17 participants; 17 VOC episodes):
  • IV hydromorphone 2 mg

  • 15 min later: IV hydromorphone 2 mg + IV ketamine 6.2 mg/kg


Control group (20 participants; 20 VOC episodes):
  • IV hydromorphone 2 mg

  • 15 min later: IV hydromorphone 2 mg + IV saline placebo

Ketamine: no data
Placebo: no data
Ketamine: no data
Placebo: no data
Ketamine: no data
Placebo: no data
Ketamine: no data
Placebo: no data
Bartolucci 2009 Ketoprofen (33 VOC episodes):
Days 1 and 2: continuous IV infusion ketoprofen 300 mg/day, 2 days
Days 3–5: 100 mg oral ketoprofen, every 8 hr, 3 days
Placebo (33 VOC episodes):
Days 1 and 2: physiological saline continuous IV infusion, 2 days
Days 3–5: oral placebo tablet, every 8 hr, 3 days
Ketoprofen: 16/33
Placebo: 19/33
Ketoprofen: 1/33
Placebo: 2/33
Ketoprofen: unclear
Placebo: unclear
Ketoprofen: 1/33
Placebo: 1/33
Benjamin 1986 Cetiedil 0.2 (16 participants; 16 VOC episodes): 0.2 mg/kg IV infusion, every 8 hr, 4 days, total 12 doses
Cetiedil 0.3 (18 participants; 18 VOC episodes): 0.3 mg/kg IV infusion, every 8 hr, 4 days, total 12 doses
Cetiedil 0.4 (13 participants; 13 VOC episodes): 0.4 mg/kg IV infusion, every 8 hr, 4 days, total 12 doses
Placebo (16 participants; 16 VOC episodes): saline IV infusion, every 8 hr, 4 days, total 12 doses
Cetiedil 0.2 mg: 2/17
Cetiedil 0.3 mg: 9/18
Cetiedil 0.4 mg: 8/14
Placebo: 8/18
"The incidence of adverse effects was similar for the cetiedil 0.3, 0.4 and placebo groups, and significantly lower for the cetiedil 0.2 group (p = 0.04). The most commonly reported AE were headache and nausea and committing, and dry mouth."
Cetiedil 0.2 mg: 0/16
Cetiedil 0.3 mg: 0/18
Cetiedil 0.4 mg: 0/13
Placebo: 0/16
Cetiedil 0.2 mg: unclear
Cetiedil 0.3 mg: unclear
Cetiedil 0.4 mg: unclear
Placebo: unclear
Cetiedil 0.2 mg: unclear
Cetiedil 0.3 mg: unclear
Cetiedil 0.4 mg: unclear
Placebo: unclear
De Franceschi 2016 Treatment group VOC1 (KTM) (10 participants; 20 VOC episodes): continuous IV infusion ketorolac 0.86 mg/kg/day + tramadol 7.2 mg/kg/day + metoclopramide 0.57 mg/kg/day, for maximum of 72 hr
Treatment group VOC2 (KT MF) (10 participants; 20 VOC episodes): continuous IV infusion ketorolac 0.86 mg/kg/day + tramadol 7.2 mg/kg/day + metoclopramide 0.57 mg/kg/day + fentanyl buccal single tablet 100 μg after 3 hr from beginning of multimodal analgesia, for maximum of 72 hr
KTM: 0/20
KTMF: 0/20
KTM: 0/20
KTMF: 0/20
KTM: 0/20
KTMF: 0/20
KTM: 0/20
KTMF: 0/20
Gonzalez 1988 Butorphanol (9 participants; 12 VOC episodes): IM butorphanol 2 mg, repeated within 30–60 min until pain relief obtained, repeat every 2–4 hr, until discharge.
Morphine (9 participants; 12 VOC episodes): IM morphine 6 mg, repeat within 30–60 min until pain relief obtained, repeated every 2–4 hr, until discharge
Butorphanol: 4/12 (nausea and vomiting)
Morphine: 4/12 (nausea and vomiting)
Butorphanol: 0/12
Morphine: 0/12
Butorphanol: no data
Morphine: no data
Butorphanol: no data
Morphine: no data
Perlin 1994 Ketorolac (10 participants; 10 VOC episodes): bolus ketorolac 30 mg; continuous IV infusion ketorolac 120 mg, 5 mg/hr, total dose 150 mg (on first day), maximum 120 mg/day, up to 5 days
Placebo (11 participants; 11 VOC episodes): bolus saline; continuous IV infusion saline, up to 5 days
Ketorolac: unclear
Placebo: unclear
Ketorolac: 0/10
Placebo: 0/11
Ketorolac: 1/10
Placebo: 0/11
Ketorolac: 0/10
Placebo: 0/11
Qari 2007 Tinzaparin (127 participants; 127 VOC episodes): subcutaneous tinzaparin 175 IU/kg, once daily, 7 days
Placebo (126 participants; 126 VOC episodes): subcutaneous placebo, once daily, 7 days
Tinzaparin: no data
Placebo: no data
Tinzaparin: no data
Placebo: no data
Tinzaparin: no data
Placebo: no data
Tinzaparin: no data
Placebo: no data
Rehmani 2013 Morphine (54 participants; 54 VOC episodes): IV morphine 0.1 mg/kg, single dose
Paracetamol (52 participants; 52 VOC episodes): IV paracetamol 1 g, single dose
Morphine: 5/54
Paracetamol: 3/52
Morphine: 0/54
Paracetamol: 0/52
Morphine: no data
Paracetamol: no data
Morphine: no data
Paracetamol: no data
Wright 1992 Ketorolac (12 VOC episodes): IM ketorolac 60 mg, single dose
Placebo (12 VOC episodes): IM saline, single dose
Ketorolac: 0/12
Placebo: 0/12
Ketorolac: 0/12
Placebo: 0/12
Ketorolac: 0/12
Placebo: 0/12
Ketorolac: 0/12
Placebo: 0/12
CPS: categorical pain scale; hr: hour; IM: intramuscular; IQR: interquartile range; IV: intravenous; KTM: ketorolac + tramadol + metoclopramide; KTMF: ketorolac + tramadol + metoclopramide + fentanyl;VAS: visual analogue scale; VCS: visual categorical score; VOC: vaso‐occlusive crisis; VRS: verbal rating scale.