Skip to main content
. 2019 Oct 11;19:100207. doi: 10.1016/j.jcte.2019.100207

Table 2.

Case control studies about the role of emotional stresses on the onset of GD.

Author (year) Relationship Study method Subjects (Number; Male, Female) Period of stress evaluation/Thyroid status at the time of study
Gray et al. (1985) [49] No Interview
Retrospective
Thyrotoxicosis (50; M39, F11)
Non-toxic goiter (50; M45, F5)
6 months prior to the first symptoms
Untreated patients
Winsa et al. (1991) [42] Yes Questionnaire
Retrospective
Graves’ disease (208; M37, F171)
Control (3 7 2)
1 year prior to diagnosis
Less than 2 weeks after diagnosis
Sonin et al. (1993) [43] Yes Interview
Retrospective
Graves’ disease (70; M12, F58)
Control (70)
1 year prior to first signs
Euthyroid after treatment
Kun (1995) [44] Yes Questionnaire
Retrospective
Graves’ disease (95; M5, F80)
Control (95)
1 year prior to diagnosis
Untreated patients
Radosaljevic et al. (1996) [45] Yes Interview
Retrospective
Graves’ disease (100; M7, F93)
Control (1 0 0)
1 year prior to diagnosis
Not available
Yoshiuchi et al. (1998) [46] Yes Questionnaire
Retrospective
Graves’ disease (228; M46, F182)
Control (2 2 8)
1 year prior to diagnosis
Within 1 month of diagnosis
Martin-du Pan (1998) [50] No Graves’ disease (98; M12, F86)
Hashimoto (95; M4, 女F91)
Benign nodule (97; F97)
Chiovato et al. (1998) [51] No Thyroid function
Prospective
Panic disorder (87; M17, F70)
Control (2 6 2)
1–30 years
No Graves’ disease
Matos-Santos et al. (2001) [47] Yes Interview
Retrospective
Graves’ disease (31; M9, F22)
Toxic nodular goiter (31)
Control (31)
I year prior to first symptoms
Euthyroid after treatment
Effraimidis et al. (2011) [52] No Questionnaire
Prospective
Euthyroid women who were 1st and 2nd degree relatives of AITD patients (521; F521) 2.7 ± 1.5 years
Untreated patients
Topcu et al. (2012) [48] Yes Interview
Retrospective
Graves’ disease (45; M12, F33)
Toxic nodular goiter (24; M7, F17)
Control (36)
6 months prior to the first symptoms
Or euthyroid after one year treatment