Table 5.
List of included studies
Citation | Country | Design | Participant # | Type of marginalization | Research question/objective |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Arden et al., 2014 | UK | Thematic analysis | 202 women | To explore women's perspectives about gestational weight gain guidance using spontaneous and naturally occurring comments made in posts on online public parenting forums. | |
Black et al., 2008 | Canada | Ethnography | 13 women | ‐Low SES | To examine the determinants of excessive prenatal weight gain in First Nations women living on a reserve. |
‐Non‐immigrant minority culture (First Nations) | |||||
‐Rural | |||||
Duthie et al., 2013 | USA | Thematic analysis | 19 women | To describe (1) what obstetricians communicate about GWG to their patients, as well as what they communicate to their patients about weight loss in the postpartum period; (2) the experiences women have communicating with their obstetricians about GWG. | |
7 obstetricians | |||||
Edvardsson et al., 2011 | Sweden | Qualitative manifest and latent content analysis | 12 couples | To explore Swedish first‐time parents' experiences of health promotion and lifestyle change during pregnancy and early parenthood. | |
Evenson et al., 2009 | USA | Thematic analysis | 58 women | To understand pregnant women's perceptions of barriers to physical activity. | |
Ferrari et al., 2013 | USA | Qualitative, not specified | 58 women | ‐Non‐immigrant minority culture (African American, Hispanic) | To gather insights into pregnant women's experiences with provider advice about diet and physical activity. |
Furber & McGowan, 2011 | UK | Framework analysis | 19 women | ‐Overweight or obese | To explore the experiences related to obesity in women with a body mass index (BMI) >35 kg/m2 during the childbearing process. |
Furness et al., 2011 | UK | Thematic analysis | 6 women | ‐Overweight or obese | To explore women's experiences of managing weight in pregnancy and the perceptions of women, midwives and obstetricians of services to support obese pregnant women in managing their weight. |
7 midwives | |||||
Garnweidner et al., 2013 | Norway | Interpretive phenomenology | 17 women | ‐Immigrant minority culture (different ethnic backgrounds) | To explore experiences with nutrition‐related information during routine antenatal care among women of different ethnic backgrounds. |
Goodrich et al., 2013 | USA | Qualitative, not specified | 33 women | ‐Low SES | To better inform intervention messages by eliciting information on perceptions of appropriate weight gain, barriers to and enablers of exercise and healthy eating, and other influences on healthy weight gain during pregnancy in overweight or obese African American women. |
‐Non‐immigrant minority culture (African American) | |||||
‐Overweight or obese | |||||
Groth & Morrison‐Beedy, 2013 | USA | Content analysis | 26 womena | ‐Low SES | To gain insight into how low‐income, pregnant, African American women viewed physical activity and approached nutrition during pregnancy. |
‐Non‐immigrant minority culture (African American) | |||||
Groth et al., 2012 | USA | Content analysis | 26 womena | ‐Low SES | To gain insight into how low‐income, pregnant African American women viewed their weight gain while pregnant and how they managed their weight during pregnancy. |
‐Non‐immigrant minority culture (African American) | |||||
Groth & Kearney, 2009 | USA | Content analysis | 49 women | ‐Low SES | To describe ethnically diverse new mothers' perceptions of gestational weight gain. |
‐Non‐immigrant minority culture (different ethnic backgrounds) | |||||
Harper & Rail, 2012 | Canada | Discourse analysis | 15 womenb | To explore how pregnant young women construct their subjectivities either within dominant discourse on health and obesity or possibly resistant discourses. | |
Hearn et al., 2013 | Australia | Qualitative, not specified | 116 womenc | To determine what online information perinatal women and primary healthcare providers want, in what form, and how best it should be presented. | |
76 primary healthcare providers | |||||
Hearn et al., 2014 | Australia | Qualitative, not specified | 120 womenc | To design and develop an online resource to promote healthy lifestyles during the perinatal period. | |
76 primary healthcare providers | |||||
Heery et al., 2013 | UK | Thematic analysis | 21 women | To explore views about weight gain and lifestyle practices during pregnancy among women with a history of macrosomia. | |
Herring et al., 2012a | USA | Grounded theory | 31 women | ‐Low SES | To understand the perceptions of urban, low‐income, pregnant African‐Americans about high weight gain in pregnancy, specifically focused on factors that contribute to higher gains, sources of weight gain advice, weight‐related health risks, and barriers and facilitators to gaining within recommended levels. |
‐Non‐immigrant minority culture (African American) | |||||
Huberty et al., 2010 | USA | Qualitative description | 32 women | ‐Low SES | To explore beliefs about health and body weight in young perinatal women. |
Jette & Rail, 2014 | Canada | Discourse analysis | 15 womenb | ‐Low SES | To explore how low‐income women of diverse sociocultural location construct and experience health and weight gain during pregnancy, as well as how they position themselves in relation to messages pertaining to weight gain, femininity and motherhood that they encounter in their lives. |
Keely et al., 2011 | UK | Qualitative, not specified | 8 women | To explore obese women's perceptions of obesity as a risk factor in pregnancy and their experiences of NHS maternity care. | |
Keenan & Stapleton, 2010 | UK | Thematic analysis | 60 women | ‐Overweight or obese | To use longitudinal interview data from large‐bodied women in their transitions to motherhood, to explore how this powerful biomedical discourse plays out in women's reported interactions with maternity professionals in pregnancy, birth and the months that follow. |
Khazaezadeh et al., 2011 | UK | Framework analysis | 12 women | ‐Overweight or obese | To interview obese pregnant women and obese women trying to conceive to identify and understand the healthcare needs of service users in Lambeth in south‐east London. |
Krans & Chang, 2011 | USA | Grounded theory | 34 women | ‐Low SES | To identify pregnant, low‐income African American women's barriers and facilitators to exercise during pregnancy. |
‐Non‐immigrant minority culture (African American) | |||||
Lindhardt et al., 2013 | Denmark | Phenomenology | 16 women | ‐Overweight or obese | To examine the experience of women with a pre‐pregnant BMI > 30 kg/m2, in their encounters with healthcare professionals during pregnancy. |
Mills et al., 2013 | Australia | Qualitative description | 14 women | ‐Overweight or obese | To explore the perceptions and experiences of overweight pregnant women attending two maternity units in Sydney, Australia. |
Nash, 2012 | Australia | Situational analysis | 38 women | To draw on longitudinal narrative data to examine experiences of weight gain and ‘fatness’ in early periods of pregnancy among women in Melbourne, Australia. | |
Nyman et al., 2010 | Sweden | Phenomenology | 10 women | ‐Overweight or obese | To describe obese women's experiences of encounters with midwives and physicians during pregnancy and childbirth. |
Olander & Atkinson, 2013 | UK | Thematic analysis | 16 women | ‐Overweight or obese | To elicit the reasons why obese pregnant women decline to participate in weight management services and to identify their barriers to participation. |
Olander et al., 2011 | UK | Thematic analysis | 23 womend | To explore the views of pre‐ and post‐natal women and health professionals regarding gestational weight gain which may inform the design of future interventions targeting gestational weight gain. | |
7 healthcare professionals | |||||
Olander et al., 2012 | UK | Thematic analysis | 23 womend | To identify characteristics of the services and support women want to enable them to eat healthily during pregnancy to make a potential future service acceptable. | |
Paul et al., 2013 | USA | Constant comparison | 26 women | ‐Low SES | To gain an in‐depth understanding of issues related to GWG including general health, diet, and physical activity among high and low income women and to elucidate socioecological and psychosocial risk factors that increase risk for excessive GWG. |
Reyes et al., 2013 | USA | Grounded theory | 21 women | ‐Low SES | To better understand the contextual factors that may influence low‐income African‐American mothers' diet quality during pregnancy. |
‐Non‐immigrant minority culture (African American) | |||||
Smith et al., 2013 | UK | Thematic analysis | 14 women | ‐Overweight or obese | To examine whether weight management guides designed for women with a BMI > 30 kg/m2, are accessible and appropriate for pregnant women with a BMI ≥ 40 kg/m2. |
Stengel et al., 2012 | USA | Grounded theory | 24 women | ‐Overweight or obese | To use interview overweight and obese women after the birth of their first child to ascertain their experiences with GWG and to identify themes on provider advice received about GWG and physical activity during pregnancy. |
Stringer et al., 2010 | UK | Framework analysis | 8 women | ‐Eating disorder | To explore the experiences of pregnant women with an eating disorder and during the early years of the child's life, including their views of healthcare provision. |
Thomas et al., 2014 | USA | Qualitative, not specified | 59 women | ‐Low SES | To develop a mindfulness‐based stress reduction and nutrition intervention for low‐income, overweight and obese pregnant women, with healthy GWG as the primary outcome measure. |
‐Overweight or obese | |||||
Thornton et al., 2006 | USA | Community‐based participatory research | 10 women and their support person (e.g. spouse) | ‐Non‐immigrant minority culture (Hispanic) | To investigate the influence of social support on weight, diet, and physical activity‐related beliefs and behaviors among pregnant and postpartum Latinas. |
Tovar et al., 2010 | USA | Qualitative, not specified | 29 women | ‐Non‐immigrant minority culture (Hispanic) | To evaluate knowledge, attitudes and beliefs regarding weight gain during pregnancy among predominantly Puerto Rican women. |
Vallianatos et al., 2006 | Canada | Qualitative description | 30 women | ‐Rural | To explore (1) Cree women's perceptions of weight gain in pregnancy and weight loss following pregnancy, (2) the barriers that women face in maintaining a healthy body weight, and (3) the sociocultural context of health. |
‐Non‐immigrant minority culture (First Nations) | |||||
‐Low SES | |||||
Weir et al., 2010 | UK | Framework analysis | 14 women | ‐Overweight or obese | To explore the views and experiences of overweight and obese pregnant women; and to inform interventions which could promote the adoption of physical activity during pregnancy. |
Wennberg et al., 2013 | Sweden | Qualitative content analysis | 23 women | To describe women's experiences of dietary information and the change of dietary habits during pregnancy. |
Note. GWG = gestational weight gain.