Table 3a-b.

Counts of participants’ causal selection responses for each of the different Question conditions in Experiment 3a (Table 3a and 3b), and for each of the different Counterfactual conditions (rows). The responses for the target of the counterfactual manipulation are highlighted in bold.

Table 3a.	Agents condition selections
CF Condition:	Admin only	Neither	Both	Prof only
Professor	7	0	35	44
Red Lever	5	1	40	23
None	7	0	53	17
Table 3b.	Artifacts condition selections
CF Condition:	Black lever only	Neither	Both	Red lever only
Professor	9	10	27	23
Red Lever	2	5	15	38
None	9	10	39	14