Table 4a-d.

Counts of participants’ responses for each of the different conditions in Experiment 4 (Causal judgments Table 4a-b, relevance judgments Table 4c-d) and for each of the different Norm violation conditions (rows). The responses for the norm violating entity are highlighted in bold.

Table 4a.	Agents condition causal judgments
Norm condition:	Admin only	Neither	Both	Prof only
Immoral	1	0	7	36
Malfunction	6	0	9	30
No violation	8	0	26	4
Table 4b.	Artifacts condition causal judgments
Norm condition:	Black lever only	Neither	Both	Red lever only
Immoral	7	1	18	20
Malfunction	0	0	2	38
No violation	6	8	24	7
Table 4c.	Agents condition counterfactual relevance judgments
Norm condition:	Admin only	Neither	Both	Prof only
Immoral	2	2	12	28
Malfunction	6	10	13	16
No violation	6	10	21	1
Table 4d.	Artifacts condition counterfactual relevance judgments
Norm condition:	Black lever only	Neither	Both	Red lever only
Immoral	3	18	16	9
Malfunction	1	1	10	28
No violation	1	24	18	2